StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Project Management: The Performance of Public Private Partnerships in Scotland - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author states that the performance of public-private partnerships transfers construction risk to the private sector more effectively than historical procurement methods and is likely to deliver value for money where there is strong competition and the projects are large. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Project Management: The Performance of Public Private Partnerships in Scotland
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Project Management: The Performance of Public Private Partnerships in Scotland"

A project can be defined as a program of work to bring about a beneficial change. We can say that a typical project starts when someone's idea is embosomed by a wider group - first informally, through discussions with colleagues and then through a more formal process (involving senior management, the management committee or board). Next they have to cope with fund-raising process. When the funding bid is successful the project can start. This means that the staff can be appointed and the work can begin. Generally, a project is characterized by: a start and an end; a multi-disciplinary team (brought together for the project); constraints of costs, time and quality; a scope of work. For example, a new piece of legislation, market imperatives, management initiatives and new technology create projects that need to be managed, often across departmental or disciplinary lines. Project Management is a methodology and a discipline which can bring significant benefits to organizations. It ensures that limited resources are used on the right projects; manages complex changes in an organized way; assesses risks, defines goals and key success area and sets quality objectives. That is why Project Management is told to be the best method of implementing change. To understand the methodology we have to analyze the project life cycle. The elements of a project life cycle are: The preparation stage - involves the project manager and sponsor and approval of an outline project justification, plan and project budget The start up stage - involves the selection and briefing of the project team and some discussion on the roles and organization The Feasibility or Research stage - establish whether the project is feasible and establish the risks and key success measures The defining and planning stage - means to plan the project in more detail by writing and publishing a full definition of the project and determining a project plan. The production of a Project Plan, or Schedule, is a key part of the development of any project. The schedule The implementation stage - involves the execution of the project as agreed The close down stage - involves the satisfactory delivery of the products or services that achieve the beneficial gain. Formal methods of project management offer a framework to manage this process and provides a series of procedures to manage the project through its life cycle. According to the Lasa Computanews Guide to Project Management, the key elements are: to define the project accurately and systematically clarifying objectives to divide the project up into manageable tasks and stages to control the project through its stages using the project definition as a baseline. Highlighting risks and developing specific procedures to deal with them. To provide mechanisms to deal with quality issues Clarifying roles to provide the basis for effective teamwork. There are lots of different project management methodologies available. But they are all variations on the same theme and have a lot in common. Many project management systems are proprietary. Project management consultants sell them as a package of services that will include training sessions and consultancy alongside documentation that will include templates and guidance notes. These packages don't come cheap - they cost hundreds or thousands of pounds. But this approach may be a cost effective solution for larger organizations that want to set up a structure to manage a number of projects. Practically, they are paying to set up a framework that includes: training for staff, consultancy and support to manage projects within the organization. However, in RCIAS Good Practice Bulletin No3 there are noted some of the common issues identified within the Research Councils or the wider public and private sectors: Procurement Strategy, Guidelines, Supply of management information, Training, Contract Signing Powers, Use of consultants. The Procurement Strategy issue is determined by the fact that few councils have a formal and authorized procurement strategy. Guidelines often contained elements of strategy but the authority for the development of best practice and the utilization of procurement skills was unclear. As RCIAS Good Practice Bulletin No3 shows, a developed strategy should provide: A clear description of procurement arrangements Authority for the timely application of procurement expertise For its application to all non-payroll expenditure wherever it may potentially add value and give assurance on propriety and regularity. A strategy approved at Management Board or council level and published widely within the Council. Best practice includes: Early participation of procurement staff Development of supplier base and modern procurement practice (procurement cards, aggregation and e-commerce) Restriction of right to negotiate prices, enter into contracts and to amend or alter contracts to procurement staff trained to exercise the necessary skills Management and enforcement of contracts to completion Standards and behavior in connection with procurement Setting of targets & performance monitoring. The Contract Signing Powers issue shows that Signing powers are defined as the authority to obtain tenders, negotiate prices and to place, manage and amend contracts. Some Councils had good clear guidance on the separation of budget authority from the authority (and expertise) to negotiate, price and to sign contracts, but did not make this as clear. The good practice should provide clear separation of authority to specify and approve expenditure (by Budget holders) from the supply of tenders and the negotiation, pricing, placing and management of contracts (by procurement specialists). Signing powers linked to a review of the procurement experience and training provided for relevant staff The exercise of signing powers periodically checked by the Council Head of Procurement or by his staff under delegated arrangements to ensure compliance with best practice (using appropriate management information). The improper use of signing powers result in their withdrawal. When changes in staff occur, signing powers not automatically transferred but reviewed centrally and formally re-issued in accordance with appropriate experience or training provided. Case Study : The Performance of Public Private Partnerships in Scotland. Procurement and Construction Performance The PPP procurement process is expensive and represents a greater burden for smaller projects. The mean time taken to procure the PPP projects surveyed was 28 months, which was generally perceived to be slower than non- PPP procurement. We note, though, that the increased costs and timescales associated with procurement should be weighed against their impact on overall timing and value for money. It is also worth noting that 'bundling' of smaller projects can help to spread procurement costs across several discrete projects. The proportion of projects delivered on time showed a significant improvement over historical experience. There was also greater price certainty during construction in the PPP projects surveyed than has been the case historically using conventional procurement. Nevertheless, on more than half of projects, the price changed at the preferred bidder stage because of a change to the design or service specification. Contractual Relationships Survey evidence showed that the majority of relationships between authorities and contractors are good. In interviews it was clear that both parties recognized the benefits of developing a long-term partnership. Payment mechanism deductions are being implemented on the majority of projects. Recommendations The evidence supports the strong view that PPP transfers construction risk to the private sector more effectively than historical procurement methods and is likely to deliver value for money where there is strong competition and the projects are large. This is clearer in certain sectors, for example water, than in others, such as health. A survey confirmed that the well known problem of transaction costs for smaller projects is also an issue in Scotland. Bibliography: 1. Caroline Low, Daniel Hulls, Alan Rennison; May 2005. Summary of initial research report on the performance of Public Private Partnerships in Scotland. Scottish Executive Publications. On the Internet at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2005/05/05153838/38399 2. Procurement Guide - Project Organization. 2002. On the Internet at http://www.ogc.gov.uk/sdtoolkit/reference/ogc_library/achievingexcellence/ae2.pdf 3. Adam, Frederic; Sammon, David; Carton, Fergal. Project Management Issues in Implementing ERP - Towards an Approach more suited to ERP Projects. On the Internet at http://www.aim2004.int-evry.fr/pdf/Aim04_Adam_Sammon_Carton.pdf 4. Morris, Peter W.G. October 2003. The irrelevance of project management as a professional discipline. On the Internet at http://www.crmp.net/papers/Moscow%202003.pdf 5. Chadwick, D.W.; Otenko, O. The PERMIS X.509 Role Based Privilege Management Infrastructure. On the Internet at http://sec.isi.salford.ac.uk/download/SACMATfinal.pdf 6. Eddowes, Lee Anthony. 2004. The Application of Methodologies in e-Government. Electronic Journal of e-Government. On the Internet at http://www.ejeg.com/volume-2/volume2-issue2/v2-i2-art5.htm 7. http://www.spottydog.u-net.com/guides/faq/faq.html 8. Bourn, John. November 1998. Guidelines on Best Practice for the Audit of Privatizations. Working Group on the Audit of Privatization. On the Internet at http://www.nao.org.uk/intosai/wgap/bestprac.htm 9. Procurement performance measures - in liabilities management. On the Internet at http://www.ukaea.org.uk/contract/downloads/ppmlm.pdf 10. Modern procurement practice in local government - local performance indicators for procurement. On the Internet at http://www.idea.gov.uk/publications/publications022.pdf 11. IMPACT ASSESSMENT & PROJECT MANAGEMENT CYCLE (PMC). On the Internet at http://www.enterprise-impact.org.uk/word-files/ProjectManagement.doc Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Project Management Master Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/business/1518281-project-management-master-assignment
(Project Management Master Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/business/1518281-project-management-master-assignment.
“Project Management Master Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1518281-project-management-master-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Project Management: The Performance of Public Private Partnerships in Scotland

Procurement route-Public Private Partnerships (PPP)- Private Finance Initiative(PFI)

Principles of public private partnerships (PPP), Merits and Demerits 2.... Procurement Route-public private partnerships (PPP) - Private Finance Initiative (PFI) 1.... Introduction The road to popularity of public private Partnership (PPP) stems from its ability to achieve cooperation towards development, health, and welfare of people amidst all forms of diversity and distance.... In fact, creating PPP is part of the core strategy of the organisation called the “Initiative on Public-private partnerships for Health,” which succeeded in forming 70 health partnerships around the world (Buse & Waxman, 2001, p....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Urban Regeneration Partnerships

hellip; Urban Regeneration partnerships ... o effectively realize and sustain the goals of urban regeneration the British government initiated partnerships with public, private, community and voluntary sectors from the fields of infrastructure, education, health, social, finance etc.... These partnerships can be explained as the sustained working joint ventures between these agencies which produce additional social benefit which could not have been produced by a purely public, commercial or charitable venture....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Government Funding of Education

There are four basic levels of education being followed in scotland, all of which are amply funded by the Scottish government.... They, too, are a part of public education.... According to the Encyclopaedia Wikipedia, public education is defined as: “Education mandated for or offered to the children of the general public by the government, whether national, regional, or local, provided by an institution of civil government, and paid for, in whole or in part, by taxes....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

How Private Security Companies are Doing Social Good and Benefitting Common Purposes

The fourth section compares the benefits and drawbacks of public partnership within the Private Security Industry Act 2001.... This study explores how state intervention through the use of private security companies working under the domain of private Security Industry Act 2001 get involved in and possibly do social good and common purposes.... Dealt in six well researched sections, the first part of the… In the second section, it investigates the role of private security in public works and the roles performed by private security for the police and other The third section discusses the power entrusted to people employed in the private security industry and their specific roles....
30 Pages (7500 words) Essay

Lochgelly Housing Development Project

The Urban Initiative for the Fife Council in scotland has prepared a report which deals with the scope of strategic growth and development in the town of Lochgelly, Scotland....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Public Service Management

?? According to Wettenhall (2003), concepts of new public management (NPM) and public-private partnerships (PPP) can be used in order to realize characteristics of convergence between public and private modes of organizing.... However, Johnston and Gudergan (2007) had stressed more on public-private partnerships (PPP) as potential mechanism to achieve the... Rather, convergence of public and private mode of organizing in public services management should Consideration of research works of Nijkamp, Van der Burch and Vidigni (2002) and Broadbent and Laughlin (2003) reveals the fact that extent of convergence between public and private modes of organising in public services management differs significantly with change in nature of public sector....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Effect of the Governments Efficiency Drive on the Social Housing Sector in the UK

This paper looks into the effects of the Public Sector Efficiency Drive to UK Social Housing Sector, in particular, the Registered Social Landlords (RSL) in scotland.... The growing budget deficit has led to enact key measures to improve public Sector Efficiency....
40 Pages (10000 words) Research Paper

A Critical Evaluation of the Management Issues Raised in the Health Care Delivery System

nbsp;… scotland's Health White Paper states “Healthcare improvement will best be delivered when the different parts of the health system work in partnership as teams of professionals and with patients.... It has become crucial for the government to forge alliances and foster partnerships with a private and public organization so that they are able to meet the growing demands of the pluralistic society with efficiency and timeliness.... nbsp; The shift is seen as an effort from “the colonization of the public realm by private sector values to a greater inter-sectoral cross-fertilization of ideas” (Ref....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us