StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

An Argument about Animal Right - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Author’s Name 05/12/2012 An Argument about Animal Right The issue of animals’ rights has attracted quite a large number of views and concerns. While some of vegetarians for instance consider killing and eating an animal’s flesh as a grave mistake by mankind, other vegetarians have other reasons such us achievement of better health (Fraser, 2000)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
An Argument about Animal Right
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An Argument about Animal Right"

Download file to see previous pages

So, are vegetarians justified when they underpin the necessity of respect to animal rights? This paper attempts to fathom to what extent these vegetarians can be convincing by summarizing the reasons for which different people eat what they eat and continue to believe in what they believe in this context. Above all, the study seeks to confirm whether animals have their distinct rights as some authors claim. First is Fraser (2000) who says that she decided to become a vegetarian for two simple reasons that: (1) she was broke and (2) she was not and had never thought to become a lesbian.

Unlike Walker’s (2004) deep conviction that killing and eating animals is predatory, and too, that it is concrete obstruction of animals’ rights of being, Fraser (2000) portrays that to her, avoiding meat and meat products was self betrayal. Fraser’s (2000) vegetarianism in the first place was volatile and induced to counter particular personal problems. But, as Fraser (2000) argues, later she became convinced that a human being ought to do what his or her mind thinks safe. At first, Fraser felt no pity for animals as expressed by her retreat to using meat and meat products.

However, later, Fraser (2000) sometimes felt that using animals thus was unjustified especially on ‘animals’ part’. . Singer argues that human beings are ruled and guided by their conscience. Singer (68) and Fraser suggest that if one feels haunted by the mere idea of killing animals in any way, then it will simply be safe to avoid both the act of killing and eating whatever meat and meat products emanating from animal killing. Well, there is no way different minds of different vegetarians could possibly be mistaken for thinking along a similar line of argument.

Walker (2004) goes even further to put her shoes in those of a chicken being slaughtered. Most religious beliefs make humans super creatures that must control and rule the earth, but according to Walker’s (2004) position, animals have their distinct rights to exist like any other creature from birth to death. Similarly, Masson (13) suggests animals are distinct entities and have their own jurisdiction but they are overpowered by other creatures, human beings. But one may counter this argument.

For example, while domestic animals are naturally highly prone to predation if left on their own, humans provide them with stiff protection. The question is; who pays for this? Animals must then pay in a way. Masson (14) says this is right but it is mandatory that they should be killed and eaten to insinuate payment and tribute to a particular farmer. But this argument may be said to be killing itself. If the farm animals are left to graze in the wild, they are killed by the wild animals. In this sense, they do not kill themselves either way.

Foer (2009) challenges the killing behavior of humans as says that humans are extraneous in this context. From collective concerns of Masson (14) for domestic animals as collective pact, Foer (2009) isolates dogs and calls them ‘man’s best

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An Argument about Animal Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1463232-an-argument-about-animal-right
(An Argument about Animal Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1463232-an-argument-about-animal-right.
“An Argument about Animal Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1463232-an-argument-about-animal-right.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An Argument about Animal Right

Comparing Two Arguments

Caras, on the other hand, argues that animals have rights and we don't have the right to inflict pain and suffering on them.... Karpati says he does not advocate a cruel treatment to animals, rather he wants the public, and the animal rights movement, to ponder on whether to choose using animals to discover treatments for the illness of a child or to let a sick child die without attempting to treat him.... Different with other animal rights advocate, he attempts to direct the public in resolving the conflict by looking for alternatives rather than by just arguing not to use animals or to continue using them as live subjects....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Man-Animal Conflict in Animal Right Issues

Even Aristotle also advocated such doctrinal view about animal right; but he holds a view which is opposite to Pythagoras'.... Name: Course: Tutor: Date: A Critical Analysis of Man-Animal Conflict in animal right Issues Introduction The question whether animals should have rights is one of the most debated topics in modern age.... Indeed, the attempt to include human being in the issue of animal rights is debated, since some people believe that inclusion of human-animal relationship into the debate on animal right violates pureness of ethicality of rights....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Ethical Issues Involved in Animal Testing

hellip; The author states that an argument that contests animal testing is the moral status animals.... Apparently, the philosophy of utilitarianism was identified with John Stuart Mill, who espoused that “in any given situation the right action would be the action that tended to minimize the suffering and pain, and maximize the pleasure and happiness, of all interested parties.... Apparently, the philosophy of utilitarianism was identified with John Stuart Mill, who espoused that “in any given situation the right action would be the action that tended to minimize the suffering and pain, and maximize the pleasure and happiness, of all interested parties....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Day-to-day Survival with Plants and Animals

Therefore, it is not safe to argue that expression is such a fundamental basis of the human right and the thing that makes individuals superior to animals.... Regan therefore is trying to emphasize the point that animals have the basic right to survive, which is technically the essence of their positive interests.... Unlike Pollan, Regan is more serious in his view to promote the idea that animals' interests should prevail, implying therefore that vegetarianism is the right way to take for the humanity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Animal Rights

McCloskey (1987) The article opens like a courtroom speech from a few hundred years ago; it appears as a structured defense of a concept that will be proved unquestionably innocent and right.... This literature review "animal Rights" puts under the examination the following articles: “Why Worry About the Animals?... istorical information regarding the growth of animal welfare groups and the inclusion of feminist connections add weight to the argument in favor of abandoning practices that harm animals....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Argument about animal rights and welfare

We need to train people and impart knowledge of animal rights and welfare, to pass on this knowledge about animal rights and welfare, so that people know the facts, and are able to separate facts from fiction (Orlans, 1998 ).... Tom Regan wrote in 2001 that theorists had written more about animal rights in the preceding 20 years than in the 2,000 years before that.... Animals have an equal right to live on this earth with us.... We need to protect what is left, it is somewhat that we must do, it is something that is inevitable for us to do right now....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethical Exploration of Animal Rights

On the other hand, considerate people opine that animals can… Some of those who are against animal-testing argue that those animals which possess consciousness and a certain level of rational capability should have the right Another group argues that the criterion of having rationality and consciousness should not be the sole basis against animal-testing; rather the fact that every animal suffers from pain is strong enough to ban animal-testing.... The “Book of Genesis” asserts that Man has a divine right over the animal kingdom....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Analyses of the Articles about Animal Ethics

The paper "Analyses of the Articles about animal Ethics " states that biomedical research on animals should continue to be done regardless of the pain the animals go through if, new vaccines are to be got, all diseases terminated and, if all medical therapies are to be improved.... This paper fully supports Cohen in his argument about animals not having rights, his definition of rights.... A right is a claim that can be exercised by one party against another (Cohen 576)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us