StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper describes the federal courts that have established the precedence of ceded powers over educational financing and state courts are emulating the policy. It is therefore expected that courts will not have future powers to make decisions on educational financing issues…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing"

The judiciary is one of the arms of the government, under the doctrine of separation of powers, in which it checks unconstitutional acts and decisions that the executive or the legislature makes. The constitution, common law doctrines, and previous court case decisions are some of the sources of law for exercising authority over issues and reliability of the sources suggest consistency for predictability of court decisions on an issue. This can be inferred to future court decisions and powers over educational financing, based on analysis of previous trends in courts’ interpretation of existing laws and decisions.

Disparity in education financing has been the major issue with the judicial system. Legal provisions for equal protection, based on the 14th amendment, have formed the basis of the litigation regarding the finances. According to the clauses, every person is entitled to equal treatment and no disparity should therefore exist on education financing (Ryu, 2015). While the courts made significant efforts in enforcing existing laws to regulate educational financing, reforms that he courts initiated had little effects in solving the financing inequality that the society realized.

Ryu further argues that court decisions on educational reforms have argued for adequacy of available education and not on financial neutrality. The ineffectiveness in previous courts’ attempt to regulate educational financing suggests lack of power to implement the decisions and indicate possible occurrence in future. The change in focus from fiscal neutrality also means possible elimination of the jurisdiction from the judicial system and suggests that the courts are not likely make decisions on the issue (Ryu, 2015).

The Supreme Court decision on fundamentality of education as a constitutional right and the court’s final decision on related cases is another indicator that courts have ceded their power on educational financing and are not likely to make any ruling on a case that seeks to challenge educational financing policies. The Supreme Court noted that education is not a fundamental right and should therefore not be considered under the equal opportunity clauses and any other amendments that provides for human rights.

In addition, the court offered a directive that such cases as cases on educational financing issues should not be brought before the judiciary and one of the arguments was involved complexity of such cases. Decision on related policies to educational financing were then directed to state legislatures and the supreme court ruling has been used as precedence in other court decision, an indicator that it may be a significant case law on future related cases. States courts in some states have since upheld constitutionality of state laws on educational financing, but this means decisions based on state laws and a shift from active judicial power to check legislations (Lunenburg and Ornstein, 2011).

Even though some state courts had made decisions on educational financing, there has been a wave of judicial pull back from the decision and the trend is expected to continue (Dunn and West, 2010).The federal courts have established a precedence of ceded powers over educational financing and state courts are emulating the policy. It is therefore expected that courts will not have future powers to make decisions on educational financing issues because of established precedence. ReferencesDunn, J.

and West, M. (2010). From schoolhouse to courthouse: The judiciary’s role in American education. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press. Lunenburg, F. and Ornstein, A. (2011). Educational administration: Concepts and practices. Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning. Ryu, J. (2015). The public budgeting and finance primer: Key concepts in fiscal choice. New Yyork, NY: Routledge.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing Essay”, n.d.)
The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1682833-future-of-education-finance-essay
(The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing Essay)
The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing Essay. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1682833-future-of-education-finance-essay.
“The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1682833-future-of-education-finance-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Court Decisions and Powers Over Educational Financing

Freedom of Expression in School Campuses

The verdict in the Pico case stated that an educational institution is not permitted to ban a book from its library just because its administrative board disagrees with the content of the book.... Censorship and freedom of expression within school campuses has attracted a lot of debate and discussion over the years.... hellip; It is a surprising fact that in a country with a rich liberal tradition like the United States, there have been over 250 attempts by school districts at book banning in 31 states....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Legal system and method

After his stint as a High Court judge in 1987 and an appeal court judge in 1995, he became a Lord of appeals in 1999 and Master of the Rolls at the court of Appeal, Civil division in June 2000.... He presided over well known trials including the appeals from Maxwell brothers and Barlow Clowes, an investment company.... He reminds that Britain has welcomed refugees from all over the world after the World War II to guarantee them protection from violation of their human rights....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Disparate Impact

The Supreme court first described the disparate impact theory in 1971, in Griggs v.... rdquo; In 1989, the Supreme court minimized the defendant's burden of proving the business necessity to a burden of producing proof of business requirement in the case of Wards Cove Packing Co.... In the example of US Supreme court Title VII case on the issue of disparate impact, in a particular case of employing laborers, the applicants needed to be high school diploma holders....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Drivers Privacy Protection Act as a General Law of Applicability

It is also important to regulate state power over citizen's personal details.... According to Axelrod, Condon claimed that the act implicated states sovereignty which granted the state all the powers even those not specified in the constitution (211).... In 2000 Attorney General Condon went to court to block the act from being enforced under the Fourth Circuit.... Reno courts at the District courts as well as court of Appeals ruled in favor of the state although the base of their argument was questionable....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Changes as Seen by the Mental Capacity Act 2005

These decisions can under the Mental Health Act 2005 pertain to their property and affairs, healthcare treatment, and where the person lives, as well as lifestyle decisions and it is stated that this end has put an end to the long and winding Government efforts to reform Mental Health Law in England.... he Act affects individuals over the age of 16 and provides for these individuals to be able to make some decisions for themselves.... The law as it stood before this Act consisted of hotchpotch pieces of legislation which current statutory schemes for Enduring powers of Attorney and Court of Protection receivership....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

To what Extent Are Men and Women Treated Differently in the Context of Equitable Remedies

The author concludes that the Equity courts do not favor men in the majority of the cases relating to separation.... Special tenderness towards women will be tantamount to differential treatment for women, and this may extend to other areas of an equitable remedy.... nbsp;… In Barclays Bank Plc v O'Brien, Lord Browne-Wilkinson had stated his opinion regarding the disadvantages of married life, particularly for women, and how modern wives were deprived of their independence due to the marriage institution....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Police Regulations: Deportation and Torture Issue

nbsp;In several non-UK cases, for example, the European court of Human Rights has held that where suspects in a police station have been beaten in order to extract confessions and information about their political activities, this was torture....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

The Powers of the US Congress

However, under enumerated powers, it has the control over the enforcement of minority rights such as that affecting African-Americans and Latinos (Dubber 89).... The paper "The powers of the US Congress " describes that the US Congress enjoys a lot of privileges and status because it is deemed as the strongest legislature.... The powers of the Congress are explicit meaning they are clearly stated in Section 8.... Therefore, this ensures that the Congress has additional powers that accord it the express authority of influencing both the budgetary and financial policy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us