StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Execution of John Brown - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The abolitionist John Brown was considered by the North as a Champion of the abolishment of slavery, but to the South, he was a criminal accused of treason, murder and fomenting insurrection. After being arrested by General Robert E. Lee of the South, Brown was tried in court and sentenced to death. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
The Execution of John Brown
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Execution of John Brown"

? The Execution of John Brown The abolitionist John Brown was considered by the North as a Champion of the abolishment of slavery, but to the South, he was a criminal accused of treason, murder and fomenting insurrection. After being arrested by General Robert E. Lee of the South, Brown was tried in court and sentenced to death. John Brown’s “Last Statement to the Court” was written in 1859 right after his last trial and after he was sentenced to death. Practically, the “Last Statement” was authored by John Brown himself and spoke of his convictions as a man and as a dedicated abolitionist. On the other hand, the statement of David Hunter Strother on the account of Brown’s execution described in full detail the final moments of John Brown before he was executed. The intended audience are the same – both Southerners and Northerners. The two documents have many parallelisms regarding John Brown’s character and beliefs, but they have a few noteworthy differences. The “Last Statement” and Strother’s Statement actually had parallelisms. Brown’s “Last Statement” is the final statement of Brown spoken after he was sentenced to death by the South. Whether it was Brown himself who wrote the speech or someone who simply noted down what he spoke, the speech seems to say one thing: the South has been wrong in its stance for slavery and the North, including Brown himself, is vindicated in their cause. The speech was wholly a denial of the charges and a testament that explained the basis of the abolition. One of the main points that Brown emphasized in his speech is a denial of the accusations previously hurled against him, and he did this with pride. He said, “I deny everything but what I have all along admitted of a design on my part to free slaves” (Author 148). For Brown, therefore, storming the armory at Harper’s Ferry was not at all a sign of rebellion but rather merely an act to free the slaves. Thus, for him, “It is unjust that I should suffer such a penalty” (149), and “I feel no consciousness of guilt” (150). The pride in which Brown proclaimed such denials somehow paralleled the “grim and grisly smirk” on his face during the execution (300) as well as the display of “bravado” and “alacrity” that he afforded his presence on the same day (300). It is actually Brown’s pride that is being shown here, although Strother’s account somehow suggests that Brown died with so much display of haughtiness – as using the words “grim and grisly smirk,” “bravado,” and “alacrity” (300). Strother must have been a sympathizer of the South for him to write the execution account like this, especially as he described Brown as “notorious” (299). However, towards the second half of Strother’s report, somehow he changes his sentiments to that in favor of Brown. He describes him as rather waiting for his death “quietly and civilly” and “without impatience” for such choice of words – “quietly” and “civilly” – somehow shows that indeed, for Strother, Brown died with dignity and honor (301). In fact, when someone seated beside Strother told him that Brown was already starting to break down –“He trembles, his knees are shaking” – Strother rather dismissed it as false (301). For Strother, it is the scaffold that shakes and not Brown’s knees, thus making the other person feel that he was wrong and that Brown here was not the cowardly guilty criminal that the man thought he was but rather a man who is ready to face death and brave enough in accepting his fate (301). What happened then to the original sentiments of Strother at the first half of the article? Perhaps, the hatred in Strother was replaced by admiration for the unflinching manner by which Brown faced his execution. The “Last Statement” actually contained more information about Brown than Strother’s account of the former’s execution. While Strother only described a man of dignity and honor standing at the scaffold, Brown’s “Last Statement” contained the religious basis of Brown’s fight against slavery, and thus contained his heart – which is something that neither Strother nor the crowd of Southerners during the execution could clearly see. Brown emphasized three subtle points. First, according to him, the reason why he got involved in the anti-slavery campaign was simple: the Bible taught him “that all things whatsoever I would that men should do to me, I should do even so to them,” and translating it in the context of the society where he moved, Brown believed that the “rights [of the slaves] are disregarded” (150). Second, he implied that the court was unjust for he pointed out that the court was using a Bible when in fact the court did not realize that what prompted Brown to be an abolitionist was also explicitly and clearly stated in the Bible. Third and lastly, Brown pointed out that some of his former companions have falsely accused him of forcing them to join – a thing which he vehemently denied and which he used as a basis for calling them weak (150). From these three points that Brown raised, the argument that he was actually trying to make in front of the court is that the court itself was ridiculous and not him. The ridiculousness of the court shows in the hypocritical use of the Bible and the false accusation and lies against an innocent man. Brown therefore had no faith in the court that tried and sentenced him to death. If we are to see in Strother’s report some traces of Brown’s lack of faith in the justice system, then it must have been in the instances when Brown gave that “grim and grisly smirk” and showed such “bravado” and “alacrity” (300). Such unusual display of confidence in him must therefore have been a sign of a distrust against the justice system and was perhaps his last sign of rebellious nature. Even his words “You will have to guide me there” (300) and “No, I don’t care: I don’t want you to keep me waiting unnecessarily,” as well as the fact that he refused to drop a handkerchief as signal, are actually statements and acts of sarcasm (301). Brown therefore belittles the execution procedures as he belittles the justice system. Thus, his honor was only his and that can never belong to such a justice system as this one which is about to unjustly remove the life out of him. John Brown’s “Last Statement” and David Hunter Strother’s report on the execution of Brown both show a consistent man who was tried in the Southern court and who believed that he was unjustly sentenced to death by a court that did not believe in the Bible upon which it was founded, and by a group of traitors who false accused him. This lack of faith in the courtroom as attested by his speech was the same lack of faith in the scaffold that Strother noticed and one which probably moved him to change his sentiments. Top of Form Bottom of Form Works Cited Brown, John. “John Brown, Last Statement to the Court (1859).” Reassessing the Presidency. New York: Prentice Hall, 2008. Print. Brown, John. “John Brown’s Body Dangles from a Rope (1859).” Reassessing the Presidency. New York: Prentice Hall, 2008. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Execution of John Brown Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1492309-the-execution-of-john-brown
(The Execution of John Brown Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1492309-the-execution-of-john-brown.
“The Execution of John Brown Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1492309-the-execution-of-john-brown.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Execution of John Brown

John Brown the Liberator

john brown THE LIBERATOR Number November 9, 2012 OUTLINE john brown THE LIBERATOR I.... john brown's life and concentration was towards liberating the oppressed and the slaves in America.... hellip; Due to American society divisions that gave some influential people power over others, john brown was determined to free the slaves from their masters by force.... Political evolution and stands had emerged during john brown's life time and later accelerated after his death, when political parties took their positions based on the slavery issue....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

John Brown's Raid at Harper's Ferry

Name Professor Course Date john brown's Raid on Harpers Ferry On the 18th of October 1859, the Republican New York Tribune reported an eruption of an insurrection at Harpers Ferry in Virginia.... During his lifetime crusade against slavery, john brown received condemnation and praise in equal measure from Americans.... john brown disgust for slavery stemmed back during his childhood.... Interestingly enough, john brown gained support from other opponents of slavery who had grown frustrated of the peaceful method....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

John Brown: Terrorist or Prophetic Hero

Instructor john brown: Terrorist or Prophetic Hero?... hellip; Over two hundred years following his birth, people perceive john brown according to different inclinations with his legacy marching on while his memory fascinates many, haunts others, and troubles many other people.... The question therefore is “who was john brown?... ?? To the people committed to social justice and freedom for all people, john brown occupies a special place in their annals....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Law of Succession

Browne is seemed to be confused about the procedures which are required for the appropriate execution of the will.... As per the ‘Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975' the name and address of an executors or executors are required to be mentioned correctly for the appropriate execution of the will of a late person2 [Barrett v Bem [2012] EWCA Civ 52]3.... brown'.... Browne is the ultimate executor of the will, he has raised the issue that his name has been misspelled as ‘brown' instead of ‘Browne' in the will....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Public Law assignment

Please note, you may not use the John Major speech for the purposes of this exercise. %PIECE YOU HAVE EVALUATED:MarkTITLEGordon brown's Commons statement on reform of the constitution.... urrency: The speech was made in 2007 after the Prime Minister Gordon brown took office in 27 June 2007.... Gordon brown proposed that the House of Commons would have to approve a resolution for any dissolution of Parliament requested by the Prime Minister....
3 Pages (750 words) Scholarship Essay

Browns Fashion Store

The main intention of this paper is to examine and document the history, products and collections and the general performance of brown Fashion store boutique.... … The paper discovers the history, products and collections of brown Fashion store boutique.... brown Fashion was established in 1970 by Joan Burstein and her husband Sidney as an independent fashion boutique in London.... brown Fashion Store The main intention of this paper is to examine and document the history, products and collections and the general performance of brown Fashion store boutique....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Framework for Ethics

This can be alluded to the successful ends that these models attain in establishing ethical culture in an organization, steer moral decision making as well as enhancing the overall execution of results (Anandarajan, 2002; Ferrell, Fraedrich & Ferrell, 2013).... To further explicate on BSC, brown (2000) posits two significant approaches to implementing it; centralized and decentralized.... In other words, Balanced Score Card (BSC) can be defined as an execution metric which is used mostly in strategic management to improve and advance various internal functions and so their resulting external outcomes (Boatright, 2009)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

American Brutus by Michael Kauffman

At the same time, stage idol john Wilkes Booth, an ardent and passionate supporter of the Confederate cause, was planning Lincoln's death.... john Booths shot Abraham Lincoln in the balcony of Ford's theatre.... This essay discusses the book American Brutus by Michael Kauffman, it analyses carried out a study on Abraham Lincoln's assassination for more than thirty years....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us