StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Making Considerations Before Contract Engagement - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Making Considerations Before Contract Engagement" discusses the case between Michael Barry and the council authority of Gloucestershire in the UK. Barry born in 1915 suffered severe dizzy spells and nausea at the age of 82 years which incapacitated her ability to perform various tasks…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Making Considerations Before Contract Engagement
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Making Considerations Before Contract Engagement"

THE JUDICIAL REASONING OF THE HOUSE OF LORDS IN R V GLOUCESTERSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL, EX PARTE BARRY (1997) AC 584 Date Facts of the Case Based on the facts, the case was between Michael Barry and the council authority of Gloucestershire in UK. Barry was born in 1915 and suffered severe dizzy spells and nausea at the age of 82years which incapacitated her ability to perform various tasks (House of Lords, 1997). She used to get around using Zimmer frame due to her hip fracture and had no contact with any of her immediate relatives. She was therefore, served sufficiently with two anonymous friends who assisted him in performing some routine duties (Aden Chambers, 2010). Under the countries disability act it is deemed statutory that individuals with such incapacitation be assisted and financed to enhance their ability to attain their potential with sustainable resources. Barry was therefore, referred to the social department of Gloucestershire council on 15 September which adequately assessed her needs and made arrangements to provide her with the services (Aden Chambers, 2010). As assessed he was to be supported with home care support for shopping, pension, laundry and cleaning services and provision of meals on wheals 4 days a week. She used to receive routine visits from the department officials where nearly after some time her needs were re assessed and identified to be the same. However, on 29 September 2004 after the review she received communication from the department stating a drop on some key services offered by the local authority citing lack of sufficient funding from the central Government (Diamond 2009, P, 345). This solidly initiated the need for legal redress to enable provision of entire services by the department. The case was heard and determined by judges as analysed below (Aden Chambers 2010). Lord Lloyd In his outset assertion based on legal provisions of the land, Judge Lloyd categorically stated that the local department had a statutory duty of providing disadvantaged individuals with necessary life essentials (Pumwar and Peloquin, 2011, p. 63). Although he ruled that the local council had no power to regulate percentage resources allocated by the central Government, he noted that local authority had an obligatory duty to discharge and that their resource constraints had no bearing. He state that once the assessment and amicable agreement was done the department in whatever state should have not reneged from providing the services to Barger (Kaldor, 2003, p.56). He stated in his ruling “The defendant’s actions were unlawful for the reason that on the sole basis of having exhausted available resources, withdrawn services previously provided or offered to the applicant pursuant to section 2 of the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Act 1970, without a lawful reassessment of the applicant" (House of Lords, 1997). He further stated that the local authority had a duty to make necessary arrangements when constrained with resources to ensure effective service delivery (Halliday 2004, p, 120). On the question whether the council is rightfully within its powers to consider available resources in assessing individuals needs. The judge concluded that on his part the authority had the right to consider and take account of their available disposable resources both when assessing needs and when deciding on how to make allocations (Cane and Conaghan, 2008, p. 341). He also stated that they have the right to adjust their arrangements to meet individual’s needs. In brief, legal procedures requires the local department to make available their services as that is their responsibility however, it was lawful for them to decide what necessities they can provide to the applicant in consideration of resource availability. Lord Nicholls’s Approach Before Lord Nicholls and Lord Clyde the case was heard and took a dynamic dimension. The case as presented before Lord Nicholls was in similar content as presented to Lord Lloyd as it was concerned to the extent to which the authority could consider resource constraints as a reason to avoid undertaking its statutory duty to the disabled (Kaldor, 2003, p. 43). Lord Nicholls asserted in his ruling that the authority had the responsibility to adopt stringent criteria when assessing the needs of the disabled under community care to enhance fairness to both parties depending on their resource capability (Jago and Barnett, 2011, p. 355). Further, he stated that local establishment should have had regard to cost effects when carrying out the assessment of Mr Barry needs to fully understand the cost implications in relation to available resources to avoid frustrating the disabled by withdrawing committed services (Oxford Journals of Legal Studies, 2012). His ruling was not in sharp contrast with Lloyds ruling since they both concurred that council had a statutory obligation to the disabled. They only had different opinion in answering the relevance of council’s right to withdraw some assistance offered to Barry. In this view Lloyd stated that all the parties had the right to consider their positions anytime to ensure fairness while Nicholls asserted that such considerations should be done before any commitment (New Law Journal 2011, p. 2.) Lord Clyde’s Contribution Lord Clyde in determining the same case rather took different approach. He strongly asserted that local authorities’ resource constraints were in no way relevant in determining the needs of the applicant however held that it was relevant in deciding whether it is necessary to make adequate arrangements to meet the needs (Hepple 2002, p. 162). He noted that needs of disabled individuals cannot be determined by resource availability due to their basic nature hence it is ,only fair that disabled individuals receive necessary assistance as spelt out in the community care act 1990 and disabled act 1970 (Spencer & Walsh 2011, P, 69). His ruling was well received by disabled individual’s who also held that the plight of their needs should not be decided with the authority but to critically asses their needs and support adequately (Oxford Journals of Legal Studies 2012, P, 9). The judge in his view further held that the concern of constraint resources by the local authority should not deny the disabled from enjoying necessary benefits (Royal Institute of British Architects 2011). His clear ruling had a different aspect contrary to other two rulings. He strongly asserted the need to respect disables benefits at all cost and failed to recognise how the councils financial argument was related to satisfying Barry’s needs. He stated the argument could only be applicable in determining whether any possible arrangements in meeting the needs are appropriate (Hannibal and Hardy 1997, p. 124). His ruling was significantly different from the ruling of Lord Llyod and Lord Clyde who asserted relevance and the right for the authority to make considerations based on their resource capacity. Conclusion It is legally clear that any contract entered between parties must be adhered to. The case between Barry and the council department best provides significance of making vital considerations before contract engagement. This was exposed when council department was constrained by resources that could enable them fulfil their obligations to the disabled. References House of Lords, 1997, Judgments -- Reg. v. Gloucestershire C.C. and the Secretary of State for Health. Ex parte Barry, London UK. Accessed 26 Jan. 2012. Aden Chambers, 2010, R (McDonald) v Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea London, UK. Accessed 26 Jan. 2012 http://www.ardenchambers.com/index.php? page=e-flash-402---r-mcdonald-v-royal-borough-of-kensington-chelsea. Halliday, S 2004, Judicial review and compliance with administrative law, Oxford, UK: Hart Publishing. Cane, P and Conaghan 2008, The new Oxford companion to law, London UK, Oxford University Press, 2008. Hepple, A 2002, Social and labour rights in a global context: international and comparative, London UK, Cambridge University Press, The New law journal, Volume 155, 2011, London UK, Viewed 26/01/2012 Kaldor, M 2003, Global civil society: An answer to war, Cambrige UK, Wiley-Blackwell Publishers Hannibal, M and Hardy, S 1997, Law for Social Workers, London, UK: Routledge Publishers. Oxford Journals of Legal Studies, 2012, Oxford UK, Viewed 26/07/2012, http://ojls.oxfordjournals.org/ House of Lords, 2011, The Law reports: House of Lords, and Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, and peerage cases, London UK, Incorporated Council of Law Reporting for England and Wales Publishers. Punwar, J and Peloquin, M 2011, Occupational Therapy Principles and Practice, London, UK, John Wiley & Sons Publishers. Jago, R & Barnett, H 2011, Constitutional & Administrative Law, New York NY, Taylor & Francis Publishers Royal Institute of British Architets, 2011, RIBA Journal, Volume 75, Issues 1-6, Social Networks and Blog, London UK, Royal Institute of British Architects Publishers. Spencer, M & Walsh, N 2011, Medicines, Medical Devices and the Law, London UK Cambridge University Press Diamond, B 2009, Legal Aspects of Physiotherapy, London UK, John Wiley and Sons Publishers. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Administrative law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Administrative law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1588076-administrative-law
(Administrative Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Administrative Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1588076-administrative-law.
“Administrative Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1588076-administrative-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Making Considerations Before Contract Engagement

Audit Engagement letter

Audit engagement letter Name Institution Apollo Shoes, [Apollo Shoes contacts] Dear Apollo Shoes, AUDIT engagement LETTER This letter confirms the understanding of objectives and terms of the engagement, and the limitations and nature of the services we offer.... Audit engagement Checklist Section 1.... engagement Performance 5.... The company will also request your company to provide written presentations from your attorneys as a section of the engagement....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Actions That Led to the Lawsuit

This is because ordinarily in contracts, when a communication is done using a different way other than that used by the offeror, then the offeror may not be liable for any miscommunication that may arise due to engagement of a different method.... The company was disappointed on the grounds that the dealer had breached the contract and in that regard filed a suit in a court to reverse the transaction made between the dealer and the other party.... The dealer on the other hand insisted that he did not reach any contract since he had not received any communication from the company and considered that the company withdrew from the deal....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

The Process of Making a Contract

The paper "The Process of Making a contract" discusses that when Labour party ascended to power, they revoked the provisions citing no legal binding in the contract, and asked Gibson to halt remitting the payments meant to complete the cost of the building.... The cost of the service went up during the discussion and Di decided to withdraw from sealing the contract.... In the first place, there was no offer and when the offer was made; Di did not make the acceptance hence making the contract....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

A Study of International Construction Contracts

However, engagement in foreign countries has definitely brought a need for regulatory measures which have been accorded through international contracts which bind the firms involved.... onclusionSuccess factors these are factors that need to be considered before a construction engagement for they determine the success of the engagement.... A contract is a binding agreement between two firms or parties which draws expectations of each in regard to the other....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Formation and Performance of the Sales and Lease Contracts

For there to be fewer conflicts in the business world, there has to be generally accepted terms of engagement.... It seeks to unveil the steps involved in entering into a contract.... A contract is a legally binding agreement between legal persons for an exchange of services and goods that are of value.... A valid contract is an emergence of a made offer that has been accepted.... Using a contract in business transactions binds the engaging parties to abide by the terms as nonperformance of the responsibilities as per the requirements of the contract may lead to a lawsuit and payment of damages....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Contract Law

A contract, also known as an agreement in some legal jurisdictions is legally binding agreement between two parties who agree to specific terms outlined in the agreement.... Entry into a contract is voluntary.... This implies that after accepting the terms of an agreement, the two parties have legal obligations to undertake their roles to the quality standards set in the contract (Frey & Frey, 2001).... A contravention to the terms of a contract The court substantiates the value of a breach thereby punishing the offending party depending on the specific breach....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Commercial Contract Law in the United Kingdom

Additionally, any sale of a product from a shop or convenience store in the country is a contract often enforceable by the courts owing to the level of engagement between the parties in the agreement and the consideration of the two exchanges.... The paper "Commercial contract Law in the United Kingdom" states that a breach of a contract refers to a scenario where a party in the contract fails to perform their obligation as stipulated in a contract....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Project Managment Adjudication

This discussion talks that financial constraints and breach of contract between the main contractor and subcontractor might have developed delay and dispute between the two contractors necessitating adjudication procedures and implementation to resolve conflicts.... ... ... ... This essay stresses that one of the relevant case law that is vital to the meeting includes the observation of local democracy, economic development, and Construction Act 2009....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us