StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law - Speech or Presentation Example

Cite this document
Summary
My Lady, I am Alisha Hussein, and in this matter on behalf of the prosecution, I shall be dealing with the issue of loss of control which states that: A person may be convicted of manslaughter and not murder if he/she exhibits loss of self-control that had a qualifying trigger,…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law"

Issue of Voluntary Manslaughter – Loss of Self Control R V Duncan Moore Issue of Voluntary Manslaughter – Loss of Self Control My Lady, I am Alisha Hussein, and in this matter on behalf of the prosecution, I shall be dealing with the issue of loss of control which states that: A person may be convicted of manslaughter and not murder if he/she exhibits loss of self-control that had a qualifying trigger, and an individual of the same age and sex in the situation might have taken the same or similar action given they have self-control and tolerance1.

What is loss of control? In the case of R v Richens [1993] 4 All ER 877; loss of control was established to be complete loss of awareness where a person is not in control of his actions. In the case, your honor, the defendant confronted the victim for raping his girlfriend. The defendant stabbed the victim and he died. He was convicted of murder, but later appealed on the defense of loss of control. The defendant’s appeal was dismissed on the grounds that he was aware of what he was doing. It was established in the ruling that loss of temper cannot be confused with loss of control.

Loss of control is defence only where the mind is not in control of the body. The defendant in the case before us today was aware of what was going on around him during the attackIf it pleases your Honour, I would go through the qualifying triggers under section 55 (3) (4) of the Act in relation to the case at hand, to demonstrate why loss of control should be withdrawn. The defendant did not express any serious fear towards the victim either by words or actions. The victim was merely acting in defense of his friend, knowing a little more than what he saw after being woken up.

Instead of fighting back, was it possible for the defendant to surrender? The defendant, in the case before my ladyship today, used force that was more than reasonable in his situation. In the case of R v Martin (Anthony) [2002] WRL1; [2002] CAR 27 Crim LR 136; the defendant shot a burglar (the victim) and argued that it was out of self defence. The defence was not available because the level of force used was more than reasonable. The defendant was convicted of murder. In his witness, Detective Sergeant Philip Dennis said that the defendant was examined and it was found that the damage was not too severe and he was fit to be detained and interviewed.

This shows that the victim attack did not threaten the life of the defendant and it was unreasonable to stab him. In the tape recording of the interview, the defendant expressed no remorse that the victim was dead. Was the defendant in this case your honour seriously wronged by the victim’s words and actions leading him to act out of character? I believe not. The defendant’s behaviour provoked the victim to attack him, therefore the qualifying trigger of seriously wronged is not available in this case (Sections 55(6) (a) and (b)2.

In R v Johnson [1989] 1 WLR 740: allow me my lady to give a brief summary of the facts of this case. The defendant argued he was acting on self-defence since he believed he was about to be glassed. He was still charged with murder because he provoked the victim by threatening his lady friend. In conclusion, my ladyship, I ask: how would a boy of fifteen years in the same scenario as the defendant who has ordinary levels of self-restraint and tolerance react?BibliographyCoroner and Justice Act 2009 (commencement no.

4, transitional and saving provisions). Order 2010, paragraph 14.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law Speech or Presentation”, n.d.)
Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law Speech or Presentation. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1627377-evidence-proof-argument-and-criminal-law
(Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law Speech or Presentation)
Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law Speech or Presentation. https://studentshare.org/law/1627377-evidence-proof-argument-and-criminal-law.
“Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law Speech or Presentation”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1627377-evidence-proof-argument-and-criminal-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law

Research of self-defence case

It emerges that the prosecution embraced the Bishop criminal law previously.... It is against the law for unauthorized persons to possess the illegal firearms.... The prosecutor refers the charges with respect to Belcher's murder reiterating that his act contravenes the state law regarding human conduct.... According to the prosecutor, the law presumes malice from the homicide and therefore Belcher is guilty of the offense.... In his response to the judgment of the jury that warrants the jury to charge Belcher for murder and voluntary manslaughter, the prosecutor finds the inference of malice regarding the use of the deadly weapon as no longer being a good law in South Carolina....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Key Differences Between Civil Law And Criminal Law

udgment is given according to the different sources of evidence that are availed in cases… Key Differences between Civil law and criminal law.... These laws include the criminal law, which deals with crimes and legal punishment in which the offenders are accorded the due punishment and; and civil laws, which is designed to settle disputes between two people or organisation and ends up in the compensation of the victims.... Crimes falling under the criminal law are divided into two categories according to the punishment length of incarceration and the severity of the cases....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Combined DNA Index System in the Criminal Justice System

CODIS has "been a revolutionary tool for law enforcement in that it enables investigators to compare evidentiary samples found at a crime scene with DNA samples collected from known convicted offenders.... Through the utilization of both DNA typing and housing these samples inside CODIS, law enforcement agencies have put many criminals away and has reduced the wait time on identifying samples from crime scenes by referencing the database.... ackground InformationSince the pilot project of CODIS in 1990 begin with 12 states, it has become an important crime solving tool for police departments for both recent cases involving the criminal element as well as an effective tool for cold case detectives....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Criminal Law or Burden of Proof

The term paper "criminal law or Burden of Proof" states that Many are the times when people have watched movies and films which dwell on criminal investigations and legal drama.... The civil and criminal cases have different definitions of its application and each individual ought to be well informed about the same.... nbsp; … The paper demonstrates that the burden of proof is something that is less complex in understanding its application but quite hectic in applying it in a court of law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Criminal Evidence, Arguments in Relation to Hearsay

In this case, Maggie's arguments may not be admissible owing to the fact that she cannot provide proof to support her idea that she heard the information/rumor from heard party.... This alarm caused high levels of tension and scare among other college students; therefore she has been taken to court… In order to provide substantial evidence, the prosecutor and the attorney has invited a witness (Mr.... The other issue that arises in this case is the fact that Miss Maggie is not in position to provide evidence by showing the court the exact person who uttered these words; instead she seeks assistance from her defendant concerning this matter....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Role of a judge and role of a defense attorney

The defense attorneys should therefore create substantive argument and interpretation with all reference to the prevailing law so as to ensure sound and ethical arguments in presenting their case prior to nullifying the proof beyond reasonable doubt of the prosecution.... At all times, it is the living role of a judge to make sure that the law is followed.... At all times, it is the living role of a judge to make sure that the law is followed....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Burden Of Proof in Civil Cases

The defendant does not have to proof his/her innocence but in the state stands in a court of law as a reference point.... This research article “Burden Of proof in Civil Cases” argues that despite the importance of the burden of proof in establishing liability of the defendant, it marked by considerable shortcoming that has led to inaccurate verdicts.... hellip; The author states that the burden of proof is a critical aspect of adjudication systems....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Humes Posteriori Argument against Miracles is not Valid

The 'a priori argument' argues that miracles are incredible events that cannot be believed because I) The testimonial evidence will never provide enough verification conclusively, that one has occurred (this is his main point), and 2) by a miracle's definition and principle (of violating natural law), it cannot be believed (a sub-point) (Spencer 99).... "Hume's Posteriori argument against Miracles is not Valid" paper argues that although the first of Hume's three 'a posteriori argument succeeds in showing that there may be no miracle proofs, it doesn't show that there is not a sufficient probability for establishing our test case....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us