StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Literature from the Aftermath of the Vietnam War - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary

This paper 'Literature from the Aftermath of the Vietnam War' tells us that the two poems Orphanage, by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I Met You in the Orphanage Yard, by Thich Nhat Hanh, are to be found side by side in a book of poems collated by Philip Mahony. They are poems about the Vietnam War.
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Literature from the Aftermath of the Vietnam War
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Literature from the Aftermath of the Vietnam War"

February Collateral Survival: Literature from the Aftermath of the Vietnam War The two poems Orphanage, by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I Met You in the Orphanage Yard, by Thich Nhat Hanh, are to be found side by side in a book of poems collated and edited by Philip Mahony. They are poems about the Vietnam War, a conflict which - like many others - has produced a wealth of art and literature in its wake. Perhaps the catharses of poets can be seen as something good that emerges from even the most dire of humanity’s inhumanity. Here, a comparison and contrast will be draw between the two poems which, though on the surface similar, have in their essence all that is different about the effect the war left on its contestants. The word orphanage is an ugly one. It has Dickensian overtones of cruelty to children who are already dealt the dreadful catastrophe of losing their parents. These days, there are few or no orphanages in the Western world: the economies of prosperous countries are such that their birth rates are dropping, with the result that any unparented children quickly find a home. The aftermath of war, anywhere, however, brings about a raft of children whose fate is to survive (Williams 2003) and to find themselves at the mercy of host countries after being herded into orphanages in the theatre of conflict itself. Because conflicts kill, and kill mostly adults. Global diasporas caused by wars carry many streams of people (Williams 2003) many of whom are children. The two poems in the spotlight show a surface similarity - they are both about children left parentless by war, but, since they are written by a woman and a man with a polarity of cultures, many differences - subtle and overt - are to be found. Larsen’s poem illustrates the well-meaning but wildly inconsiderate actions that take place after any catastrophe: how (generally) white Western people offer charity without thinking of the consequences, either immediate or long-term. ‘I went with balloons, hard candies, / old National Geographics’(Mahony 1998): it is bewildering to anyone who has worked with the homeless and parentless to see the perceptions of those who have never experienced a moment of having absolutely nothing, not even a Mom. Good intentions often blow up in the face of the giver, and that is what happens in Larsen’s poem: the narrator brings gifts to an orphanage, only to find herself face to face with her own misapprehensions and lack of sensitivity. This can be taken as an analogy for countries who intervene into conflicts among communities of whose culture they have little or no idea, and of well-meaning philanthropists, especially celebrities, who think they are doing good, whereas they underestimate or gauge situations badly, resulting in an altogether different mess. The giver had no idea what the outcome of her action would be (Mahony 1998). She seemed appalled by the children’s frenzied attack on her gifts. She did not understand their neediness and despair, and was shocked by what a too-small gesture could do. Perhaps she was expecting gratitude, a pat on the back, beautiful words of thanks, or broad smiles from the children. It often happens that the expected outcome is imagined before and ahead of a correct estimate of what actually is being given. The problem the giver was trying to assuage with a metaphorical band-aid was far too large to be covered by balloons, candies and old magazines. ‘I looked over to the nun for help.’ The giver is out of her depth (Mahony 1998) The most important are the nun’s words at the end of the poem, “Next time, if you come,/ Bring enough for everyone, or bring nothing.” The meaning here is explicit: those who give must think about their actions: giving is not enough. It is not the thought that counts: the consequences are extremely important. Perhaps it is a consolation to the observer that this poem was written as a kind of exculpatory confession: ‘I made a mistake, but I realize how big the problem is now.’ This is the real meaning of this poem, this moment of coming to the realization of something bigger than was previously thought, and much more serious. It takes a big person to write something like this in such a public way: an admission of insensitivity and ignorance, which might be put right in the future, because it is a metaphor for a much larger issue. Thich Nhat Hanh’s poem on the other hand comes from the same place his name does: the other side of the cultural divide. He can relate to the plight of homelessness and being orphaned because he has seen so much of this kind of thing. His poem carries an edge of knowledge: an understanding of what it means to suffer (Thich Nhat Hanh 1999). There is an undertone of meditative calm, even though the scene is sad and desperate. The child in the orphanage yard draws circles in the dust: endless shapes of sadness that will not go away. This is a metaphor of futility. Here, the poet is not giving anything: no gift, no words, even. But the reader comes away feeling there was a moment of sharing there: an element of compassion that was bigger than any gift of candy. ‘I dared not open up your wounds.’ These are words that indicate an awareness of pain. Having experienced pain is a prerequisite of counseling and working with disadvantaged people: this poet has a trace of that understanding, through identity and history. His name says everything. Contained inside a book full of similarly empathic poems, this one by Thich Nhat Hanh bemoans ‘cruelty, hatred and violence’ which inflicted upon this little orphan the fate of being completely alone (Thich Nhat Hanh 1999). No amount of sympathy or philanthropy will bring his parents back, and that is very well expressed here. ‘... and your fingers will draw again / those small circles / of pain...’ The meaning here is a felling of helplessness by the poet who knows there is very little anyone can do to relieve the inevitable suffering of a young orphan. The two poems have a history in common: of a war that left a wake of thousands of homeless children, many of which were transported to adoptive homes all over the world, including the USA. They also have in common a certain amount of powerlessness. And there is the effect on the reader, who can take away lessons from both the poets. There are huge differences though: the poem by the Vietnamese monk is devoid of analogy, intended or otherwise: it is a straight and plain poem that describes the plight of a little one in a dusty yard, whose present is empty of love and comfort and whose future is full of uncertainty (Thich Nhat Hanh 1999). And the picture of the adult who watches and is struck speechless by the situation, but is full of empathy, is clear and unambiguous. The poem by the white overwhelmed woman, who tries her best to do good but finds her efforts are not only undersized but also misguided, is a capable analogy of the bigger global picture of what happens when the uninitiated dabble in troubles they do not fully understand. She stands and watches as her gifts are misused and torn to shreds under the young hands of orphans who themselves do not understand why she has brought what she has brought. Mutual misunderstanding is the misfortune here, and it happens a lot in intervention that means well but is not researched properly. The two poems are simply written, without complication or hard words to send the reader to dictionaries. their difficulty does not lie in language: it lies in distinguishing what is really being said. The Vietnam conflict was not a simple affair: it was long, cruel, miscalculated and wreaked havoc not only in the theatre where it took place, but left its indelible mark on the United States of America, whose dead, injured and permanently disabled fighters numbered in the hundreds of thousands. There are white orphans of the Vietnam war too: they are invisible in these two poems, but their plight was perhaps not so hopeless and desperate. ‘You turned your face away.’(Thich Nhat Hanh 1999) Those who suffer for reasons of war do so in a terrible way. Both these poems emphasize the futility and cruelty of such wars, and try to warn against the consequences of such conflicts. If the wisdom from these experiences, such as is held in these two simply-worded poems is heeded, the world need not have to care for orphans any more (Williams 2003) Sources Cited Thich Nhat Hanh, (1999) Call Me by My True Names Parallax Press Mahony, Philip (1998) From Both Sides Now Scribner Paper Fiction Williams, Indigo (2003) Not Quite/ Just the Same/ Different: the Construction of Identity in Vietnamese War Orphans Adopted by White Parents AustralAsian Digital Theses Program (ADT) Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Orphanage, comment on Orphange by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I met You in Essay”, n.d.)
Orphanage, comment on Orphange by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I met You in Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562795-orphanage-comment-on-orphange-by-wendy-wilder-larsen-and-i-met-you-in-the-orphanage-yard-by-thich-nhat-hanh
(Orphanage, Comment on Orphange by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I Met You in Essay)
Orphanage, Comment on Orphange by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I Met You in Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562795-orphanage-comment-on-orphange-by-wendy-wilder-larsen-and-i-met-you-in-the-orphanage-yard-by-thich-nhat-hanh.
“Orphanage, Comment on Orphange by Wendy Wilder Larsen and I Met You in Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562795-orphanage-comment-on-orphange-by-wendy-wilder-larsen-and-i-met-you-in-the-orphanage-yard-by-thich-nhat-hanh.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Literature from the Aftermath of the Vietnam War

Effects of Vietnam War on American Society

The public lost faith in the government in the aftermath of the war.... Network television, music and even Hollywood made the vietnam war almost a part of the American culture.... the vietnam war was referred by some as the worst occurrence in the then 200 year history of the US.... There is no other point in history where Americans had as low an opinion for public institutions as the period after the vietnam war.... Name: Course instructor: Course: Date: Effects of vietnam war on American Society America?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Politics in Itself Can be a Major Force in Determining Growth and Development of a ountry

Vietnam-Politics and economic growth Background & reshuffling the power structure The country of Vietnam has gone through almost three decades of war.... As a consequence, a war broke out between Vietnam and France where France was defeated in the North Vietnam with the outbreak of a civil war.... Now with the communal tensions being one of the predominant phenomenons at that time the Americans involved themselves in war with Vietnam, the...
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Culture's Portrayal of the Vietnam War

he vietnam war presented America with a foreign policy, a military action, and a public response that certainly had plenty to be critical of.... The movie Good Morning Vietnam (1987) chronicled the vietnam tour of Armed Forces Radio disc jockey Adrian Cronauer, and was one of the more accurate versions of the war from the soldier's point of view.... To be clear, there was no one singular experience for the vietnam veteran.... However, the barrage of pop culture images that stereotyped the vietnam veteran as a ticking time bomb has had a significant negative impact on these...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Kent State University Shootings And The Boston Massacre

The shootings at Kent University went down in history as the turning point of the vietnam war era.... Richard Nixon won the 1968 election promising to end the vietnam war, but failed to stick to his promise.... Nuclear disarmament movement and Civil rights movement in the USA of the late 1950s - early 1960s, Anti-vietnam war movement in the USA and worldwide of the mid 1960s - early 1970s, students movement in the USA of the mid 1960s - early 1970s, women's movement in the USA that began in the late 1960s and soon spread to Europe - these are only most notable examples of such events....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Colonialism in American Literature of Vietnam War

Robert Olen Butler (The Alleys of Eden) 1981This fictional narrative centers on Clifford Wilkes, an American soldier trapped in Saigon at the closing of the vietnam war.... The author states that the involvement of the American government in the war judged by critics slash historians as taking the nature of colonialism renders the bulk of American literature on the vietnam war as largely colonial in structure, content, and focus.... (29) Since the vietnam war is the result of America's efforts to participate in the colonization endeavor of Europe in an era of decolonization, the subsequent literary product is essentially and categorically colonial....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

The Impact of the Vietnam Conflict

the vietnam war was initially a conflict between two new countries that came out of the French colonization of Indochina.... 37) Although there are three main players in the vietnam war: North Vietnam, South Vietnam, and the United States, there is the important addition of the Soviet Union as an actor and to a certain degree, China, that the vietnam war came to be characterized by the conflict of two factions, the Communist and the US-South Vietnam alliance....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Analysis Of The Vietnam In Me And In The Lake Of The Woods

The aim of the paper "Analysis of the vietnam In Me And In The Lake Of The Woods" is to make an analysis of two different literature pieces of the same author, the New York Time article 'The Vietnam in Me' and a novel 'In the Lake of the Woods' by Time O'Brien.... Flashbacks are employed by O'Brien to present various events and his experience in vietnam war as a soldier.... The author cannot omit to write about what is in his mind and what is haunting his thoughts day after day and night after night even after years since the last war action....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien

The book is therefore dedicated to the Alpha Company men who were part of the vietnam war with him.... In one sense, O'Brien seeks to address the events of the vietnam war.... soldiers fighting in the vietnam war.... Tim O'Brien uses various semi-autobiographical characters in narrating the vietnam war ordeals.... O'Brien wanted to ensure that the pieces would be capable of reflecting and absorbing the light of other stories (O'Brien 25 In writing the 'Things They Carried', O'Brien mainly centers on a platoon of soldiers and the vietnam war....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us