StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Buchanan, in this article, deals with the widely held beliefs (or fear or anxieties) about the possibilities of producing an enhanced human species through biotechnological interventions that can, then, raise claims to a higher moral status and a different set of human rights…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half)"

Moral Status and Human Enhancement by Allen Buchanan Buchanan, in this article, deals with the widely held beliefs (or fear or anxieties) about the possibilities of producing an enhanced human species through biotechnological interventions that can, then, raise claims to a higher moral status and a different set of human rights. Although even such possibilities are ‘yet to be explored’ the issue does raise concerns as the materialization of such a possibility can very well bifurcate human beings into enhanced and unenhanced or rather ‘persons’ and ‘post persons’.

It is precisely the possible cleavage between these two categories, the problems that could be resulted in due to the persisting gaps that are under question in this essay. Buchanan treats this larger question under two subsets, the first of which deals with the question “If enhancement did result in posthumans, what implications would this have for the concept of human rights: would it make that concept obsolete, as some have claimed; and if it did, would this be a moral catastrophe, as they have intimated?”. The second subset, which and the further sections are under analysis in this paper, deals with the question “Could the emergence of post humans result in there being a moral status higher than that of persons and hence require a rejection of the widely held Moral Equality Assumption, the assumption that all who have the characteristics sufficient for being persons are of equal moral status?” (353).The second question which rather addresses the concerns regarding privileging the enhanced group of persons – post persons – and thus resulting in a higher moral status raises questions regarding the very basic assumptions regarding moral equality.

Buchanan, in the second section, contemplates on this basic assumption and challenges those concerns on the basis of the “inviolability”, which should be understood as a threshold concept, of this assumption (363-364). That greater “personhood” does not confer “greater inviolability” seems to question the belief that ‘persons’’ interests might be sacrificed in the interests of the ‘post persons’ (364). Even in times of “supreme emergency” when persons might literally have to be sacrificed for the benefit of many it does not follow that there is a difference between the values of the former and the latter (364).

Buchanan justifies himself by referring to instances of racism, ethnic minorities, developmental and physical disabilities etc., where similar concerns popped up and were dealt with on the basis of the assumption of the inviolability of equal assumption. That even when one section of the human beings (that is the white, especially from the West) indeed emerged as supreme beings over the rest of the population (that is the rest but especially the Black) the gap thus resulted was mitigated and then abolished altogether on the basis of this assumption.

The same is the case with the other instances.Nevertheless he adds to another dimension of the same problem by bringing in the instance of card players’ group where there is conflict of interests and capabilities; that some of them ‘can’ play bridge whereas others ‘cannot’ reflects the extent to which the ‘can’ group need to adjust for the ‘cannot’ group (373-374). This reflects upon the ‘fact’ that one group will have to adjust and cannot proceed with its “legitimate interests” (374-377).

The same scenario recurs in the participation of economic and political processes where the minimal competency of the unenhanced “persons” is under sever threat. The fact that their very participation is seldom if not nil makes it necessary for enhanced “post persons” to compensate for such a disability in the form of commodities etc., which can’t last for long. Buchanan calls this the failure of the “enhanced cooperation” (378). Through the instance of how human beings dealt (and still dealing) with people with developmental disabilities Buchanan shows how even in the present there exists ‘differences’ between people with different capabilities.

Hence the issue at hand is not the creation of a higher moral status but a “practical worry” that concerns about the reflections of such persisting gaps in capabilities and interests (369-375). That there are some who possess a higher level of intelligence and practical reasoning could seem to invite inequalities that will have to be dealt with from a different perspective. ReferencesBuchanan, Allen. “Moral Status and Human Enhancement.” In Philosophy & Public Affairs. 37.4 (2009): 346-381

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half) Essay”, n.d.)
Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half) Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1566007-buchanan-human-status-and-moral-enhancement-summary-2nd-half
(Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half) Essay)
Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half) Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1566007-buchanan-human-status-and-moral-enhancement-summary-2nd-half.
“Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1566007-buchanan-human-status-and-moral-enhancement-summary-2nd-half.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Buchanan- Human Status and Moral Enhancement (Summary 2nd Half)

Human genetic enhancement

Human Genetic enhancement Name Institution Human Genetic enhancement Introduction Human genetic enhancement is a human biological field that revolves around the modification of human traits through the introduction of foreign genetic material into a different genetic environment.... hellip; The science surrounding genetic enhancement dates back a few decades ago, but it is till recently that more advances have been made, with numerous restrictions barring any further progress....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Human genetic enhancement

Human Genetic enhancement Name Institution's Name Introduction Genetic enhancement refers to the transfer of genetic material intended to modify nonpathologial human traits.... When the aim is enhancement, the gene may supplement the functioning of normal genes or may be imitated by the genes that have been engineered to produce a desired enhancement.... hellip; Human beings have attempted enhancement in different ways, especially on children: Music, exercise, diet, cosmetic surgery but for many people there is something deeply troubling about bioenhancement technologies because the changes magnify human biological functions beyond the norm (Mitchell, 2010)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Surrogate Mothers and Human Enhancement Dilemmas

Also, the author examines the human enhancement dilemma and  presents the argument and opinions for and against biotechnology which is often used in enhancing human nature … The surrogate agency strives to strike the best deal while leaving the surrogate mother in a position that she can hardly protect and serve her interests.... While many scholars condemn enhancement on the basis that it always destroy or alter human nature, Buchanan (2009) responds by articulating that there is no evocative reason or evidence that eliminating some bad qualities in human beings endanger the good qualities....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Human Enhancement

In the paper “Human enhancement” the author discusses the idea whether the welfare of the unborn child is considered.... Human enhancement al Affiliations Although surrogate parents and their normally sign an agreement of bearing the children, Anderson strongly opposes this idea by considering whether the welfare of the unborn child is considered.... A principled objection to enhancement gives the total interrelationship between human nature and judging good and bad character....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Ethics / Cognitive Enhancement Drugs: Buchanan/Sandel/Liao

Ethics and moral guideline governing the society may conflict with this scientific approach in dealing with human survival aspects.... Human enhancement entails progressive measures taken to overcome the human body weaknesses by improving its abilities using both standard and scientific means.... … The study and research on human enhancement cover various fields.... This emerges questions like, is human enhancement morally permissible?...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Human Genetic Enhancement

The article “Human Genetic enhancement” is an attempt to critically investigate the issue of genetic enhancement of human beings.... Is it desirable to create a world for superhumans more genetically enhanced and perhaps quite different from what we are to Genetic enhancement even speaks about trans species upper human combination of several species into one?... If some are quite hopeful about the outcome of the genetic enhancement, then some have also focused on its evil sides....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Ethics of Biomedical Enhancement

The paper “The Ethics of Biomedical enhancement” looks at ethical dilemmas relating to technological possibilities.... Indeed, in his earlier book Liberal Eugenics: In Defence of Human enhancement, Agar actually speaks in favor of enhancement.... Nicholas Agar raises another important objection to the dangers of radical biomedical enhancement.... He posits a future society where genetically enhanced post-human species would dominate (or eliminate altogether the species homo sapiens as we know it)iv....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

Comparing between Tom Buchanan and Gatsby

In his defence of the "status quo," which, as a useless millionaire, he depends on, Buchanan attempts to appear morally upright in a negative sense, by trying to unmask Gatsby's activities as a bootlegger, who collaborates with Wolfsheim, a paidup member of the underworld.... Its vanished trees, the tress that had made way for Gatsby's house, had once pandered in whispers to the last and greatest of all human dreams....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us