StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Running head: Critical Essay Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality Insert Name Insert Grade Course Insert 20 July 2012 It has been verified through a string of experiments and studies that non human animals can be moral agents (De Waal, 2008, 282-83)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality"

Running head: Critical Essay Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality Insert Insert Grade Insert 20 July It has been verified through a string of experiments and studies that non human animals can be moral agents (De Waal, 2008, 282-83). Psychologists have taken great focus on the subject by evaluating the essence of morality and investigating whether animals have the capacity to practice morality demeanor and elucidates moral qualities like, cooperation, reciprocity along with fairness and that can be observed in social animals.

From de Waal’s account, it is evident that animals especially chimpanzees can actually be moral agents. The basic concept in understanding the ability of animals to be moral agents is the evaluation of how human morality is distinguished from chimpanzee “morality”. De Waal envisages that human morality develops from the morality of our common ancestors. Morality emerges gradually, becoming more complex over time, but human morality is different in degree, not in kind, to the “morality” of other primates.

Philip Kitcher, Christine Korsgaard, and Peter Singer in their book Philosophers and Primates opine that human morality is in some respects unique: it is different in kind. They suggest that morality is often a matter of overcoming our nature. Korsgaard maintains that “A form of life governed by principles and values is a very different thing from a form of life governed by instinct, desire, and emotion; even a very intelligent and sociable form of life governed by instinct, desire, and emotion.

… We have ideas about what we ought to do and to be like and we are constantly trying to live up to them, apes do not live that way,” (Kitcher, Korsgaard & Singer, 2009, 117). She considers that morality requires a form of self-consciousness that allows us to inspect and assess our intentions. Correspondingly, Philip Kitcher asserts that “chimpanzees are … vulnerable to whichever impulse happens to be dominant at a particular moment,” (Sager, 2012, 4-8). Therefore, he hypothesizes that our ability to use language gave rise to cultural evolution that moves morality beyond its biological roots, in some respects opposing it.

According to de Waal, morality arises from the distinction between ultimate causes and proximate causes. Morality can lead to reproduction (kin selection) and reciprocal altruism: animals that engage in altruistic behavior may be more successful reproductively or in terms of obtaining beneficial cooperation from other animals. The ultimate cause is “self-interested” (Kitcher, Korsgaard & Singer, 2009, 136). However, the proximate cause may not be: that is, the immediate motivation of an animal that has evolved altruistic psychological capacities may be the best interest of other animals independently of their self-interest.

In his paper titled “The Schizophrenia of Modern Ethical Theories,” Michael Stocker laments that modern ethical theories fail to provide the right sort of motivation for morality (Stocker, 1976). The central point in the article is that modern moral theories are particularly unsuited to deal with relationships of friendship and love because they impose external obligations that are actually self-defeating. De Waal endeavors to base morality on empathy and the social emotions. Many animals, including birds, display “emotional contagion” (De Waal, 2008, 282-83).

They take on the emotional state of other animals nearby; consider babies who cry when they hear the cries of other babies. Empathy can give rise to sympathetic concern or personal distress. De Waal’s own research shows chimpanzees engaging in consolation, when chimpanzees comfort the loser of an aggressive encounter. This seems to require not only empathy, but also an ability to assess the other chimpanzee’s situation and react appropriately by providing comfort. Finally, there is “empathetic perspective-taking” in which animals enter the perspective of others and sometimes engage in “targeting helping … fine-tuned to another’s specific situation and goals.

” (de Waal, 2008, 285). Owing to the fact that we share common ancestors with other primates, it might be the case that our sense of morality is an outgrowth of earlier emotional processes. In de Waal’s perception, morality follows the “Russian Doll Model” (De Waal, 2008, 288). At the inner level, there is emotional contagion made possible by an automatic “Perception-Action Mechanism”: “When the subject attends to the object’s state, the subject’s neural representations of similar states are automatically and unconsciously activated.

” (de Waal, 2008, 286). In conclusion, non-human animals can be moral agents because animals especially chimpanzees and other primates have the ability to express the emotions of empathy and consolation that are associated with morality. In spite of the fact that there are certain defining features of human morality that are different in kind from the psychological and social features of non-human social animals such as chimpanzees, the studies conducted by Frans de Waal are proof enough that animals could actually be agents of morality.

References De Waal, F. (2008). Putting the Altruism Back Into Altruism: The Evolution of Empathy. Annual Review of Psychology 59, 2008: 279-300. Kitcher, P., Korsgaard, C. & Singer, P. (2009). Philosophers and Primates. Washington: Princeton, NJ. Pierce, J. & Bekoff, M. (2009). Wild Justice: The Moral Lives of Animals. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Sager, A. (2012). UNST 249: Morality (Lecture notes). 4-8. Stocker, M. (1976). The Schizophrenia of Modern Ethical Theories. Journal of Philosophy, 73(14), 1976: 453-466).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1454183-critical-essay
(Non-Human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1454183-critical-essay.
“Non-Human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1454183-critical-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Non-human Animals Can Be Agents of Morality

History of Behaviorism

The paper "History of Behaviorism"  describes the rise and fall of Behaviourism that can be charted historically against related developments in the discipline of Psychology which drew upon its findings and experiments but simultaneously leveled a critique of its methods and biases.... hellip; The use of Behaviourism to manipulate and control people in mass societies shows how destructive the effects of reducing a human being to a machine or animal can be because it denies the higher morality, ethics, creativity, and awareness that is required to make critical decisions in the face of historical problems like war and the Holocaust....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Animal Liberation

This is occasioned by the fact that any author who attempts to tackle the controversial question must have a standard of morality that the supposed “moral saint” satisfies.... Cohen argues that rights can only be restricted to moral agents.... However, Cohen's fails to show how humans without the ability to claim their rights can enjoy rights.... Cohen's speciesist theory failure to explain how humans without the capacity to claim rights can enjoy moral rights assists Utilitarianism answer his criticism for their explanation of animal rights....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Animal Testing: Pros and Cons

Critics of animal testing argue that testing on animals is unscientific, unreliable, and a violation of our morality.... The medical community and advocates of animal testing can point to a long history of success in the use of animals for medical research.... Cosmetics are applied to mammals to While animals have been a large part of product research and have been instrumental in revealing dangers or indicating safety, opponents contend that the research on animals is unnecessary and unjustified....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Sustainability and Environmental Ethics on the Future of Life

Let us examine the leading perspectives on environmental ethics, assess on what matters the notions are wanting, and define what can be a better notion of environmental ethics.... Atkisson argues that the difference between ethical and moral is that morality refers to our feelings while ethics pertains to what people generally accept as moral (1-2).... Our sense of… Essentially, ethics refer to reflections between right and wrong, judgment on the good and the bad, and determination of It is important to have a good notion of right and wrong that can guide our action....
11 Pages (2750 words) Admission/Application Essay

Animal Behavior Society

It can be argued that fighting against speciesism is another chapter in the long struggle for equality in the human history.... According to Richard, it is not a coincidence, as either one can be a caring individual who recognizes and values other beings or one can be selfish caring only for self.... The present essay entitled "Animal Behavior Society" argues over the idea that the humanity and its worth is more should not be judged in light of an ape-centered morality but rather on the basis of a human-centered morality....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Toxic Effects on the Structure of DNA

The fate and behavior of Pb in the environment is quite complex because of the many compounds of Pb and that can be found and the... Lead (Pb), a metal with an atomic weight 207.... and atomic number 82, is soft bluish-gray acid-soluble element, exhibiting a bright luster when freshly cut, but tarnishes in moist air to form a dull gray coating....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Philadelphia Primate Head Study

In May 1984, Animal Liberation Front (ALF) activists intruded the deserted Philadelphia campus of The University of Pennsylvania and took several videos of animals suffering during various head tests (Orlans 71).... People for the Ethical Treatment of animals (PETA) made claims that the videotapes showed actions of repeated violations of federal policies that govern the humane use of animals in research laboratories (Orlans 71)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Should Animals Have Rights Like Humans Do

All creatures can be victims of injustice, however, only moral agents are capable of committing the injustices, this is because of it only them who can violate rights.... The respect principle, however, states that the moral agents should coexist with the other moral agents or patients without harming them for this will be disrespecting their inherent value, and according to Regan it is from this that the rights are formulated and therefore creatures who have inherent values have basic rights....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us