StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Plato's Apology through Socrates - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Plato's Apology through Socrates" makes it clear Plato indicates that the unexamined life is not worth living. Socrates begins by indicating this since his purpose in life is being a philosopher, for him, it is essential to living an examined life - the highest virtue and worth…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Platos Apology through Socrates
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Plato's Apology through Socrates"

Philosophy Over the of Plato’s career, his works span an enormous array of s. Indeed, his writings through the Platonic dialogues constitute some of the foundational elements of the Western philosophic tradition. Plato’s Apology considers Socrates trial in front of the Greek lawmakers who have accused him of undermining the Athenian youth through teaching them his knowledge and wisdom. A Greek citizen, Meletus, has brought these claims against Socrates. The Apology then represents the entirety of Socrates’ argument to the court to prove his innocence and demonstrate the absurdity of Meletus’ claims against him. In this effort, Socrates bravely presents arguments relating to the need to life the examined life, as without living a life of purpose and meaning he believes there is no purpose in existence, and the examined life is the highest such pursuit an individual can pursue in life. This essay considers Plato’s characterization of the examined life through his dialogue the Apology and then advances a counter argument that ignorance is bliss. Apology One of the most seminal of Plato’s dialogues, the Apology constitutes Socrates’ argument to the Athenian court for his innocence. Throughout Socrates’ argument there is the thematic undercurrent that in teaching wisdom and spreading the truth to the Athenian youth he is pursuing the right path, and that to cease doing so and live an examined life to prevent the court form taking his life is not worth doing. The first instance where Socrates indicates as much occurs in his rebuttal of Meletus, when he states, “a man who is good for anything ought not to calculate the chance of living or dying; he ought only to consider whether in doing anything he is doing right or wrong - acting the part of a good man or of a bad” (Plato). Socrates goes on to explain how according to Meletus’ reasoning the men who died valiantly at the battle of Troy were wrong in doing so. One of the primary complaints that Meletus levies against Socrates is his argument that Socrates has corrupted the youth by advising them not to believe in the gods. In refutation of this Socrates seems to argue that he actually embraces a belief in the gods, just not in the form that is traditionally accepted in Greek culture. Instead, Socrates embracement of the gods comes in terms of his purpose in life, which is living the examined life. In these regards, Socrates states, “God orders me to fulfil the philosophers mission of searching into myself and other men, I were to desert my post through fear of death, or any other fear; that would indeed be strange, and I might justly be arraigned in court for denying the existence of the gods, if I disobeyed the oracle because I was afraid of death” (Plato). Here Socrates is indicating that since God has made his purpose that of a philosopher, then the core element of his existence is to live the examined life, so that ultimately Meletus’ claims that Socrates has corrupted the Athenian youth by expounding on the knowledge he gained from living the examined life is erroneous as he has done this out of following the purpose God or the gods placed him on Earth. While this is an interesting rebuttal, perhaps the most notable element of this discussion is the relevance it holds for the current examination of the examined life, and the importance contextualizing Socrates perspective in terms of the argument. While the prevailing wisdom of individuals only cursorily familiar with Plato’s statement through Socrates that the unexamined life is not worth living generally understand it to mean that Socrates is speaking to all individuals; they believe that Socrates is stating that any individual who chooses not to live an examined life, or the life of a philosopher is unjustified in doing so, when in actuality Socrates is indicating here that this is true only for him. As the Apology continues Socrates keeps with this line of reasoning, and seems to expand his earlier statement to include all men. In considering Socrates’ reasoning it’s important to consider the broader implications of Socrates argument. It seems that Socrates is indicating that in Meletus and the Athenian counsel harming Socrates they are doing so in a sort of bad faith. Socrates believes that in being a wiser than Meletus he has chosen to live his life virtuously. In living his life virtuously Socrates has contributed to society and lived his life in productive ways. He has also worked towards achieving his own sense of purpose and meaning; in Socrates’ instance, it seems that he believes this to be living honestly and spreading his wisdom and intellect to the Athenian youth. If Meletus were to have Socrates killed, which he is attempting to do, it would not harm Socrates has lived his life in accord with the principles set out before him and done so in a virtuous and just way; therefore, in dying Socrates has simply realized the potential his life had for him. Socrates is indicating then that he would rather die than not engage in seeking and spreading truth and wisdom. This leads him to state, “the greatest good of man is daily to converse about virtue, and all that concerning which you hear me examining myself and others, and that the life which is unexamined is not worth living” (Plato). In these regards, Socrates is indicating that in not living his life purpose of spreading and examining wisdom then life is not worth living. Furthermore, while earlier he indicated that the examined life was his purpose, here he is indicating that in living the examined life humans are pursuing a life of the highest virtue and worth. Ignorance is Bliss While through Socrates Plato indicates that the unexamined life is not worth living, there are a number of means by which a critic could refute this claim. In terms of the Apology perhaps the most pervasive claim relates to the actual means by which Socrates has become engaged in the court proceedings. As Socrates has become embroiled in this court issues because he has been a speaker of truth and wisdom one might consider if it would have been better for him to simply live a life where rigid examination of such philosophical issues wasn’t as central an aspect of his existence. It seems in Socrates regard, his seeking of truth and wisdom has so centrally gone against Greek culture’s mainstream beliefs that it caused problems within that society. While Socrates might argue that he was only attempting to seek truth through rational thought, one can question what purpose there was behind him finding this truth. To consider the issue utilizing the same logic Socrates implements with his philosophical arguments, one might ask Socrates what is the purpose of life. In these regards, I believe most people would indicate that the purpose of life is to gain the most enjoyment without inflicting pain or duress on other individuals. It follows then that in seeking to live the examined life, Socrates has gone about ignoring both of these tenants. Regarding the first tenant, it can hardly be indicated that seeking to live the examined life is the most enjoyable means of spending one’s time. Surely Socrates has a number of hobbies that he would rather pursue, such as fishing, cooking, or even watching Greek sporting events, than he would deep philosophical issues. There is also a sense that in seeking the truth of things, one does not discover a greater sense of happiness, but instead a greater sense of despondency as the ultimate reality is not something that is always happy to understand. For instance, in the Apology one of the greatest charges that Meletus brings against Socrates is that he has attempted to undermine the prevailing beliefs in the Greek gods. While Socrates’ views on this subject are accurate, there may be a deeper purpose for this belief in the Greek gods. For example, it’s highly probably that many individuals in contemporary American society embrace a belief in Christianity because it contains a belief in the afterlife and is extremely comforting. Similarly, in undermining the Athenian youths’ belief in the Greek gods, Socrates is undermining this comfort and sense of security. Considering the second tenant of the issue, namely that individuals should not harm other individuals, it seems that it’s possible Socrates has violated this tenant. Ancient Greek culture, and indeed contemporary society, is structured on the cooperation of individuals with each other to achieve a harmonious working environment. One of the conditions that society has to achieve this harmonious cooperative atmosphere is for society to agree on a number of basic assumptions and values; these include things that generally fall under the categorical distinction of laws. It follows then, that in living the examined life and preaching his findings to the Athenian youth, Socrates has sought to undermine the very values that unite Greek society in this harmonious and cooperative environment. It follows that Socrates’ way of life has sought to harm other individuals, as without this cooperative aspect it would be impossible for individuals to achieve many of the things that are needed for their subsistence. Conclusion In conclusion, it’s clear that in the Apology through Socrates Plato indicates that the unexamined life is not worth living. Socrates begins by indicating this since his purpose in life is being a philosopher, for him it is essential to live an examined life. Later Socrates extends this argument to indicate that in living the examined life humans are living a life of the highest virtue and worth, so that living an unexamined life is not worth living. While Socrates presents a compelling argument, a counter-argument that ignorance is bliss is explored that argues the examined life may present issues that are problematic to the individual and society. References Plato. Trns. Jowett, Benjamin. "Apology." MIT Classics. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Oct 2010. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Plato's Apology through Socrates Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 22, n.d.)
Plato's Apology through Socrates Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 22. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1742779-philosophy
(Plato'S Apology through Socrates Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 22)
Plato'S Apology through Socrates Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 22. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1742779-philosophy.
“Plato'S Apology through Socrates Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 22”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1742779-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plato's Apology through Socrates

Plato's _Meno_ discussion

Name Professor Course Date Plato's Meno Discussion Meno was one of the dialogues written by Plato that explored different philosophical thoughts and accounted for a view of the perspective of socrates.... hellip; According to socrates, Meno can convince Anytus regarding the lessons of virtue which had been concluded during the dialogue, and then a new perspective which is considered beneficial to the Athenians can be achieved.... But why is the discussion of virtue significant to socrates?...
1 Pages (250 words) Dissertation

Socrates's wisdom

In conclusion, this essay has examined plato's apology.... socrates' Wisdom Plato's the Apology is one of the seminal texts of ancient Greek philosophy.... The text contains socrates appeal to the Greek council that is trying him for a number of accusations.... The story socrates tells in the Apology about Chaerephons visit to the oracle constitutes a defense against the earlier accusations made against him.... This essay considers how socrates' story functions as a defense....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Idea of Justice

In the Apology, Plato explores the notion of justice through socrates' trial and defense; conversely, Epicurus' writing is generally relayed through point-by-point aphorisms.... This essay examines these notions of justice in plato's apology and selections from Epicurus.... This essay examines these notions of justice in plato's apology and selections from Epicurus.... One of the predominant aspects of justice in plato's apology and selections from Epicurus is the nature of the medium of expression....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Social Foundation - (provided in Details section)

On the contrary, modern Chinese is fairly simple and does not require much literal knowledge In plato's apology, the use of the term “Apology” misleads the reader to think that Socrates was actually apologizing for the purported mistakes.... However, as the text goes along, the reader realizes that socrates was actually defending himself from the accusations.... Also, according to Plato, the Apology is a form of dialogue in which socrates engages his accusers while trying to justify his actions....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

In What Sense Does the Case against Socrates Show that His Idea Challenged the Good Order of Society

Name: Instructor: Course: Date: In what sense does the case against socrates show that his ideas challenged the good order of society?... socrates trial appears to have been a culmination of a series of events throughout his life as an independent thinker and a philosopher.... According to Plato's (socrates close friend) account, socrates prosecution was masterminded by Anytus, a leading democrat.... In the years before socrates trial, the Tyrants had taken over Athens, these were lead by Critias, a former pupil of socrates (Brickhouse and Smith 26)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Apology of Socrates

The essay under the title "The Apology of Socrates" demonstrates that plato's apology strikes a deep chord among readers for it elucidates the meaning of philosophical pursuit made clear by the words of its main character and Plato's teacher, Socrates.... hellip; “The Apology of socrates” is Plato's version of the speech given by socrates in his defense of the charges of corrupting the youth and creating new deities brought up against him by men of Athens....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Socrates Apology

As a dissenting member of the jury sitting within the courtroom on the case reported in plato's apology, I felt it important to write down my thoughts regarding the charges that were brought against one Socrates.... socrates is an older gentleman, generally considered ill-kept,… It is difficult enough for us to keep the peace in these trying times, and we all know the gods must be kept appeased if we wish to avoid any catastrophes.... It is generally considered a poor choice to have the accused speak for himself, and it could be argued that socrates didnt do himself any favors in attempting to present his case....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Plato Is the Epitome of Western Science and Philosophy

Together with socrates and Aristotle, who was his… To illustrate his brilliance, it is often said that in his thoughts received little to no criticism because few philosophical minds could rival his.... His only serious rival was socrates, Module Plato Plato is the epitome of Western science and philosophy.... Together with socrates and Aristotle, who was his student, Plato defined philosophy like no one else could at the time (Pojman and Vaughn 47)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us