StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Use of Rewards and Punishment as Motivations - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Use of rewards and punishment in order to motivate other members of the organization
This paper sought to present an argument against the notion that people in powerful positions in organisations must use rewards and punishment in order to motivate other members of the organisation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Use of Rewards and Punishment as Motivations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Use of Rewards and Punishment as Motivations"

Download file to see previous pages

Essentially the people who have greater power are often the one in control of what motivational tool to use in order motivates the members of the organisation. Notably a long held method for motivating people within a group has been through reward and punishment with the rationale for such motivations being that people often have the desire to avoid punishments and gain rewards (Deci and Ryan, 2008). While leaders may tap into such motivations in order to control resources and tools of sanctioning, there has been a wide debate as to the efficiency in the use of rewards and punishment given that such method of motivation is extrinsic, and the human mind may respond differently to rewards and punishment.

This paper argues against the notion that people in powerful positions in organisations must use rewards and punishment in order to motivate other members of the organisation. While the use of rewards and punishment is a widely used tool for motivation in various institutions and organisations, it is hardly challenged especially taking into account the desirability of rewards such as praise or monetary rewards. Reward entails the use a positive reinforcer to encourage certain behaviours, while punishment is the use of a negative reinforcer to deter undesirable behaviours.

The use of rewards and punishment is an idea that was popularised by Skinner in the 1930s where he noted that humans were motivated by external factors where people responded to expectations of rewards for desirable behaviour and punishment for undesirable behaviour (Strickler, 2006). Skinner’s view has been deeply entrenched in most organisations’ motivational strategies where members of an organisation would be highly motivated with an opportunity for higher earning. This theory makes sense since truly people do get motivated by financial incentives as noted by the high level of programs such as performance reviews, bonus programs, and merit pay programs that have infiltrated society from schools, homes and organisations.

Over the past decade, other studies have shown that by trying to manipulate or condition people in following certain desirable behaviours has not been an effective method for ensuring long term motivation. For instance Kohn (1993) in his book shows that using rewards and punishment as motivational tools only produce short term results while it is detrimental in the long term as it encourages internal competition for rewards where when there is no reward, people would not be motivated, and also destroys intrinsic motivation and relationships.

Essentially group cohesiveness and social arousal are essential motivators that can be nurtured in environments that that build relationships rather than one which pits the members against each other in competition. Deci and Ryan (2000) in their work also show that the use of rewards and punishment assumes that human beings are innately lazy and unmotivated, yet that is not true in its entirety as human beings are often have motivations that only need to be boosted. Tyler (2002) in his study of motivations for members in an organisation to cooperate, note that while rewards ad punishment are important, they would not in their entirety enable sustainable motivation as they do not draw out individuals internal motivations that appeals to a person’s values and attitudes.

A focus in competing for rewards is not the best way to motivate cooperation among members. In addition, withdrawal of rewards that was already there for one reason or another may be deemed as punishment even if that is not so. Indeed Deci and Ryan

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Use of Rewards and Punishment as Motivations Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1451364-people-in-powerful-positions-in-organisations-must
(Use of Rewards and Punishment As Motivations Essay)
https://studentshare.org/psychology/1451364-people-in-powerful-positions-in-organisations-must.
“Use of Rewards and Punishment As Motivations Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1451364-people-in-powerful-positions-in-organisations-must.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Use of Rewards and Punishment as Motivations

A Learning Situation

On the other hand, because the child is aware that failure to complete the task allocated in time will lead to punishment, he or she will attempt to complete it in time.... In essence, the reward to attain from the parent and the teacher is a positive condition that leads to completion of homework in time whereas the punishment is a negative condition that leads to diminution of failure to complete homework in time.... In this case, a child may complete his or her homework in time to earn rewards from her parent or teacher....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Organizational Behavior in Health Care

Description of Reinforcement Theory of Employee Motivation The Reinforcement Theory of Motivation works mainly along with four parameters: Positive and Negative Reinforcements and punishment and Extinction.... Traditional Theories related to motivation focus on rendering an effective analysis of the job environment or work atmosphere of an individual and the different types of rewards needed to enhance the performance levels of the employees.... Positive and Negative Reinforcement criteria generally focus on motivating an individual's performance through the generation of rewards....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Punished by Rewards

In his book, Punished by Rewards: The Trouble with Gold Stars, Incentive Plans, As, Praise, and Other Bribes, Alfie Kohn presents a compelling argument against the use of rewards.... Kohn discusses the parallels between punishments and rewards and suggests that both are punitive in nature: both exercise control, and if one does not receive the expected reward for any reason, the withholding of the reward is a form of punishment (51-2).... Kohn states that “both rewards and punishments induce a behavior pattern whereby we try to impress and curry favor with the person who hands them out” (58)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Reward And Motivation As Factors For The Productivity

The objectives of the study "Reward And Motivation As Factors For The Productivity" are to examine the motivational reactions of individuals towards incentives, rewards, and recognition and to analyze the relationship between rewards, motivation, and performance of individuals....
31 Pages (7750 words) Dissertation

Long-Term Care Hospital Workplace Motivation

An individual who is highly self-motivated will benefit most when managers successfully convey that productivity goalmouths that must be me are of use to them.... In this essay, the researcher seeks to probe, uncover and report the various motivational strategies Long-Term Care Hospital (LTCH) embrace and collapse my discussion to demonstrate how such motivational strategies affect the Hospital's productivity....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Issue of Employee Motivation

The tools such as fringe benefits, performance-based compensation, rewards, paid holidays, job security and even empowerment are considered to be implemented in the workplace in order to gain the most out of employees (Wubbolding, 2002).... The author of the current research paper "The Issue of Employee Motivation" mentions that motivation is an inner force that pushes the employees to go a step further when completing their tasks....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper

Student Motivation Strategies

Moreover, it incurs a minimal cost to educators and parents for external rewards and students are typically more productive.... The paper "Student Motivation Strategies " states that Intrinsic motivations are long-lasting; they come from within an individual.... According to Wiseman and Hunt (2014), a student can be extrinsically motivated when he or she engages in learning basically for the sake of attaining a reward or avoiding some inevitable punishment related to failure to do so....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

How to Increase Student Motivation to Complete Their Homework

Others argue that homework contribute significantly to students' negative attitude towards the school and teachers especially if it is a source of conflict between students and a parent or is linked to punishment and other consequences either at school or at home (Wiseman & Hunt, 2014).... According to Wiseman and Hunt (2014), a student can be extrinsically motivated when he or she engages in learning basically for the sake of attaining a reward or avoiding some inevitable punishment related to failure to do so....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us