StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood" highlights that Capote is found opposing the death penalty placed on this case and rather proposes that it would have been more reasonable and satisfying deciding on a life sentence on the two…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood"

The Background Information on Death Penalties of Perry Smith and Richard Hickock The story of Perry and Richard outlines a background information on death penalties that were executed on the two characters. The author informs that Smith and Hickock were two prisoners who came to know each other at the Kansas State Penitentiary during the year 1956. According to the individual historical backgrounds of each of the two prisoners, they became criminals out of family related issues and desperations. While in prison, it is suggested that Hickock and Smith socialized closely with another prisoner by the name of Floyd Wells. Wells informed them about how rich Herb Clutter, his former employer was ruthless. From the information given, Hickock and Smith mistakably comprehended that Clutter used to keep a lot of money in his house. So both of them planned that immediately after their release they would go and rob Clutter and escape with his money. Therefore, I support that Perry and Richard were justified to be given death penalties. Perry and Richard were justified to be hanged since both characters were a threat to the society. After their release, they did as planned but they didn’t get the money since Clutter rarely kept any money in the house. The two criminals ended up killing the whole family and escaped. Church mates are noted to be the ones who first noted the disappearance of the Clutter’s family in Church and decided to make a follow up. Their efforts led them to Clutter’s house in which they found only dead bodies. This is said to be realized on the second day after when the criminal event had taken place. The police were notified and in the process of making investigations, Wells informed the authorities that he had discussed about Clutter’s richness with Hickock and Smith and so they became the first suspects. Further investigations are mentioned to lead to the arrest of the two criminals a month after in Los Vegas and were brought to Kansas where they were charged for the murder case of the Clutter’s family. The two confessed while agreeing with the charges but their statements contradicted each other about who killed who. Nevertheless, the two murderers were both charged and sentenced to death by hanging and which took place in 1965. Both characters were fathers of controversy and deserved to be hanged. The statements that each of the two criminals (Hickock and Smith) is informed that Smith agreed that he had cut Clutter on his throat and shooting Kenyon and Herbert Clutter on their heads while aiming from a closer range. About the killings of two women, Nancy and Bonnie Clutter, Hickock and Smith gave contradicting statement about who killed these two women, however, it is later found that Smith agreed that he killed all of them in order to cover up for Hickock. But Smith’s confession is said to have not been officially made since he refused to make it in court (Adams, 2015). Blanco (n.d) documents further claims made in regards to the judgment made in the murder case of the Clutter’s family. These claims are raised questioning the accuracy results or rather how accurate was the evidence presented which had been used by the court to decide this case. These queries are mentioned to have been brought up by Truman Capote in 1966 after publishing his novel “In Cold Blood” about Richard Hickock’s and Perry Smith’s killing the Clutter’s family. This query is constructed as follows: That the investigator to this case Alvin Dewey, began to suspect Hickock and Smith five after the murder event, when Wells informed that he had heard Hickock planning to rob Clutter and kill any witness to the event. This information made Dewey make follow ups with Hickock’s parents inquiring about the whereabouts of their son. In their home, Hickock’s gun was found that matched the forensic results. Thus, the two (Hickock and Smith) became prime suspects to the Clutter’s murder case. However, this prime detail is claimed to have been collected by the police five days after it had been given clues by Wells. Thus, question raised by Capote’s novel is, why did Dewey delay to gather such information? In response to this answer, the prosecutor to the case argued that initially, Dewey had found no evidence linking the two criminals to the Clutter’s murder and as a matter of fact, he had strongly believed that it was a local person whom Herbert Clutter had been at loggerheads. The court was also justified to pass death penalty on the two characters since they were actively involved in cold blood activities. Another issue raised by Truman Capote’s novel “In Cold Blood” is about the punishment (death penalty) that Hickock and Smith were administered to when this case was decided by the Kansas court. As a matter of fact, this punishment made these two criminals become very popular in America. This information is said to have been gathered by Capote and his research assistant Harper Lee while in their attempt to make a story how this case impacted the American’s community in general. And in the process also, Capote also had managed to gather some primary information from the two criminals as well which he used to develop the novel ‘In Cold Blood”. Following up with the court case, it is informed that the dual criminals had made several attempts to appeal for a review of their punishment but this failed. Some of the guiding principles used to evaluate the punishment as too harsh on the dual criminals are listed as follows: (a) the case showcases the limitations in which courts consider mental status of the wrong doers especially when they were found to fail agreeing on who killed who and Smith carrying all the blame. The judge to this case, Mr. Tate is noted to have ignored to have the two defendants undergo a comprehensive mental test and thus, rather than a psychiatric, judge Tate ordered the law practitioners to interrogate the two criminals and relied on these results to decide the case (Blanco, n.d; Miller, 2015; Watson, 1994). In spite of the tragic accidents that both characters had endured, they deserved the penalty since they were involved in bloody activities. Their historical backgrounds were never considered in the case but involved criminal and cold blood activities. As in the circumstances that had made the two enter into crime had not been reviewed. For instance, for Smith, in his quest to rebuild his life, he had a serious motorcycle accident that had badly affected his legs made him take too much of aspirin which made him become addicted to it and this perhaps is conveyed could have interfered with his sanity. Also, for Hickock who also had been involved in an accident and hit his head which made him be admitted in hospital for a couple of months, the outcomes of his head injury are also being advocated may have some impact on Hickock’s sanity. However, in response to this, it is explained that from the legal perspective, one is said to be insane if he or she cannot understand why he or she has done act and cannot tell whether the act is right or wrong. This argument is further developed that a psychiatrist was only involved to make judgments about the acts of the duals when evaluating the nature of the bodies lying on the floor in Clutter’s house. That is, the psychiatric was required to evaluate the criminals’ state of mind using the nature of acts established at the site of crime. The answers that the psychiatric would give are said were only limited to yes or no answers with no further comments. Based on such claims, Capote is found opposing the death penalty placed on this case and rather proposes that it would have been more reasonable and satisfying deciding on a life sentence on the two (Blanco, n.d; Miller, 2015; BBC, 2015). Why this paper Supports Capote’s Opposition to Death Sentencing of the Dual Criminals What has been gathered as guiding principles by Capote in challenging court’s decision (death penalty), are very much compelling. In that, historical information about the duals in terms of assessing their sanity status would have explained whether the two were in their right states of mind to execute such a murderous act which involved young teenagers of 15 and 16years. This consideration would have been triggered by the contradicting statements given by the two criminals (Ricketson, 2015; Capote, 2000-2011; Capote, 1975). To reinforce the opposition further, Adams (2015) explains about the development of death penalty law in Kansas. It is informed that this region has never had a standard rule of law that determines when to apply the death penalty judgment since its inception. This law has been facing several eliminations and reinstatements during the 1990s. Moreover, the State of Kansan during this period had not yet introduced life imprisonment punishments and thus, death penalty was perhaps seen as the best way to close the case. References Adam, S. (2015). Death Penalty: Kansas Continue to Debate Capital Punishment Decades Later. Retrievedhttp://www2.ljworld.com/news/2005/apr/06/death_penalty_kansans/. BBC (2015). In Cold Blood-The Book that Changed Me. Retrieved< http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-30846163>. Blanco, J. I. (n.d). Murderpedia. Retrievedhttp://murderpedia.org/male.S/s/smith-perry.htm. Capote, T. (1975). In Cold Blood. New York: Transaction Publishers. Capote, T. (2000-2011). BookRags Literature Study Guide: In Cold Blood. Retrieved https://www.bookrags.com/checkout/?p=guides&u=brick-lane. Miller, L. (2015). Truman Capote’s Greatest Lie. Retrievedhttp://www.salon.com/2013/02/14/truman_capotes_greatest_lie/. Ricketson, M. (2015). Truman Capote and the World He Made. Retrieved< http://meanjin.com.au/editions/volume-69-number-3-2010/article/truman-capote-and-the-world-he-made/>. Watson, A. (1994). Capote’s Bias: In Cold Blood as an Anti-Death Penalty Argument. Retrieved< http://home.insightbb.com/~adamwatson/showcase/capote.html>. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood Research Paper”, n.d.)
The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1693273-essay-on-truman-capotes-novel-in-cold-blood
(The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood Research Paper)
The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1693273-essay-on-truman-capotes-novel-in-cold-blood.
“The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1693273-essay-on-truman-capotes-novel-in-cold-blood.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Inhumanity of the Death Penalty in Truman Capotes In Cold Blood

In Cold Blood, Part 2 Analysis

Order#: 509807 Topic: in cold blood pt.... in cold blood Part 2 is about questioning of the Dick and Perry by the detectives.... Order 509807 Topic: in cold blood pt.... in cold blood Part 2 is about questioning of the Dick and Perry by the detectives.... in cold blood; Random House, January 1966... in cold….... truman Capote writes about their mixed feelings, “Some day they'll get to the bottom, and when they do they'll find the one behind it....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

In cold blood section 3

[Your full name] March 15, 2010 in cold blood- Section 3 In section 3 of his nonfiction novel, in cold blood, the author, Truman Capote, shows Floyd Wells in the Kansas State Penitentiary listening to the radio news about the Clutter murders.... [Your full March 15, in cold blood- Section 3 In section 3 of his nonfiction novel, in cold blood, the author, Truman Capote, shows Floyd Wells in the Kansas State Penitentiary listening to the radio news about the Clutter murders....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

In cold blood final section

Name Subject Professor Date in cold blood by Truman Capote Summary: Final Chapter (pp.... in cold blood by Truman Capote Summary: Final Chapter (pp.... Works Cited in cold blood: A True Account of a Multiple Murder and Its Consequences.... hellip; Andrews killed his family, and his case, just like Dick and Perry's, paved the path for a medical and legal campaign where lawyers begin looking into the possibilities of using environmental factors and psychological accidents or imbalances to defend criminals against the death penalty sentence....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Cold Blood by Truman Capote

in cold blood by Truman Capote illustrates that human nature is represented with both sides (good and evil).... Truman Capote's book in cold blood was based on the real murder in 1959 of a wealthy Kansas farming family by two men who were at the time on parole: Richard (Dick) Hickock and Perry Smith.... in cold blood by Truman Capote illustrates that human nature is represented with both sides (good and evil).... Truman Capote's book in cold blood was based on the real murder in 1959 of a wealthy Kansas farming family by two men who were at the time on parole: Richard (Dick) Hickock and Perry Smith....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

An author of this paper seeks to investigate the role of stereotypes and histories in the novel "in cold blood" written by Truman Capote, discussing particular character lines.... The writer of this essay claims that both stereotypes and histories are central to this novel.... hellip; Stereotypical notions, even in their open defiance of basic logic and rational thought, still have a strong hold upon even the best educated mind....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Literary Analysis of the book :In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

Patricia Perea English 101 December 11, 2012 “in cold blood”, by Truman Capote In his nonfiction novel, in cold blood, the author, Truman Capote, has focused more on the murderer's motive behind the act, instead of searching for who the murderer was.... Capote has told the reader about the Clutters' death before depicting the actual scene, which increases the reader's interest....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

[Your full name] November 22, 2013 in cold blood by Truman Capote Prompt 2- Suspense In his nonfiction novel, in cold blood, the author, Truman Capote, has created suspense by focusing more on the murderer's motive behind the act, instead of searching for who the murderer was.... Fahy (251) writes: “The horror of in cold blood operates on several levels: its realism, the brutality of the crime, the random selection of victims…the incongruity between the primary motive (theft) and the ultimate outcome (multiple murders)…” Suspense rolls in when readers come to know that Floyd talked to the authorities about Dick out of guilt....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Malleability of Nonfiction in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

Truman's work is what is referred to as “New Journalism” based on what it exhibits to the readers (Capote The Malleability of Nonfiction in truman capotes in cold blood In Cold Blood, written by Truman Capote's is a true master piece.... in cold blood.... truman demonstrates great writing skills and detective knowledge when he investigates and follows keenly a murder of involving the whole of the Clutter family.... truman demonstrates great writing skills and detective knowledge when he investigates and follows keenly a murder of involving the whole of the Clutter family....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us